Episode 47: "The Attendance Problem Nobody Talks About"
Chronic absenteeism hits a comprehensible input classroom differently than a worksheet-based one, and this episode of Comprehend THIS! is about exactly that gap. Pamela and I talk through what happens when a student misses a chunk of story or a running joke that can't be handed over as makeup work, and how to actually help them catch back up.
A student who's been gone six of the last ten days walks back into a CI classroom and has missed something that doesn't exist outside the room it happened in. In this episode of Comprehend THIS!, Pamela and I talk about the specific student we each think of first when this topic comes up, the makeup-work attempts that completely missed the point, and the systems we've actually built for kids catching up after long absences.
We also get into how to keep a returning student from feeling lost on their first day back, and what we wish administrators and attendance policies understood about how chronic absenteeism specifically affects a language classroom where the curriculum lives in the room itself. This one leans into patience and advocacy, because absences are rarely something a student is choosing.
Not sure where your comprehensible input skills actually stand right now? Take the free CI Proficiency Quiz and find out in a few minutes: https://imim.us/ciquiz
If you want a done-for-you way to keep your CI instruction consistent, including for students catching up after absences, check out the CI Survival Kit - monthly, ready-to-teach materials built with real classrooms in mind: https://imim.us/kit
CONNECT WITH US
Subscribe to the podcast: https://imim.us/live
CI Proficiency Quiz: https://imim.us/ciquiz
CI Survival Kit: https://imim.us/kit
comprehensible input, chronic absenteeism, CI teaching strategies, world language teacher, TPRS, language teacher podcast, makeup work for absent students, Spanish teacher, French teacher, attendance in language classrooms
Hosts:
Scott Benedict - https://www.instagram.com/immediateimmersion
Pamela Parks - https://imim.us/pamela
Kimberly Floyd - https://instagram.com/@language_forward
https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/store/language-forward
Resources & Links:
CI Survival Kit: https://imim.us/kit
Dynamic Discipline: https://imim.us/discipline
Join the Conversation:
Got thoughts or your own story?
Share it in the comments or tag us @ImmediateImmersion!
Watch & Subscribe:
👉 Watch LIVE or replay on YouTube: https://imim.us/live
👉 Listen on your favorite podcast app: https://imim.us/podcastlinks
👉 Never miss an episode: https://imim.us/comprehendthis
Connect with Scott:
Host: Scott Benedict — Immediate Immersion
🌐 https://immediateimmersion.com
📧 Scott@immediateimmersion.com
Youtube: https://youtube.com/immediateimmersion
Instagram: https://instagram.com/immediateimmersion
Facebook: https://facebook.com/immediateimmersion
TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@immediateimmersion
Transcript
Good morning everybody and how is
Speaker:everybody doing this morning?
Speaker:Today there's a kid who's been gone six
Speaker:of the last ten days.
Speaker:You know that kid. Happens all the time.
Speaker:I know I've got lots of kids going out
Speaker:for Thanksgiving break already.
Speaker:We give them a whole week already and
Speaker:they're already leaving early for that.
Speaker:So we know those
Speaker:kids. We have those kids.
Speaker:And every time they walk back through our
Speaker:door, they've missed
Speaker:a chunk of the story,
Speaker:an entire running joke, a piece of
Speaker:comprehensible input that
Speaker:doesn't exist as a worksheet,
Speaker:you can just hand over.
Speaker:It's so much easier when you have a
Speaker:textbook you say, "We covered pages 14 to
Speaker:18. Go ahead and get done to it."
Speaker:But we don't do that.
Speaker:You can't compress a
Speaker:classroom into a packet.
Speaker:Believe me, I have tried.
Speaker:This week I'm getting
Speaker:chronic into absenteeism,
Speaker:specifically inside a CI classroom where
Speaker:the curriculum lives in the room
Speaker:and doesn't travel well to
Speaker:a folder labeled "miswork."
Speaker:Pamela and I are talking about the
Speaker:student I think of first
Speaker:when this topic comes up,
Speaker:the make-it-work attempts
Speaker:that completely missed the point,
Speaker:and what I actually do now for a kid
Speaker:trying to catch back up.
Speaker:If you've ever watched a student walk in,
Speaker:lost, after a long absence,
Speaker:and felt your stomach drop a
Speaker:little, this one's for you.
Speaker:And we had a guest host today, Kimberly.
Speaker:Unfortunately, she emailed me
Speaker:at 2 in the morning, poor girl.
Speaker:She is sick this morning,
Speaker:so she won't be with us.
Speaker:So I just want to wish her well.
Speaker:And Pamela and I will hold down the fort,
Speaker:and we'll be right back
Speaker:after these short messages.
Speaker:"Love teaching but hate the part where
Speaker:you're the classroom bouncer?"
Speaker:Yeah, same.
Speaker:Enter dynamic discipline.
Speaker:No, it's not a boot camp for kids.
Speaker:It's a course for
Speaker:teachers who are tired of saying,
Speaker:"Stop licking the whiteboard
Speaker:for the five hundredth time."
Speaker:You'll get 10 on-demand lessons full of
Speaker:realistic relationship-based strategies
Speaker:that actually work without turning into
Speaker:the teacher who yells
Speaker:or gives up and plays Netflix.
Speaker:Watch them on your time, re-watch when
Speaker:you're having a week,
Speaker:and start handling
Speaker:behavior without losing your soul.
Speaker:Sign up now at mm.us.discipline.
Speaker:Your sanity will thank you.
Speaker:Welcome to Comprehend This, real talk for
Speaker:real language teachers.
Speaker:No drills, no dry theory, just honest
Speaker:stories, practical ideas,
Speaker:and a reminder you're not
Speaker:alone in the CI trenches.
Speaker:Let's dive in.
Speaker:And welcome, Miss Pamela.
Speaker:How are we doing this today?
Speaker:Doing great.
Speaker:Kim, we miss you.
Speaker:We'll get you back on again.
Speaker:It's ironic that you're sick on the day
Speaker:we're talking about sick students, so...
Speaker:I didn't think about
Speaker:that, but that is so true.
Speaker:That is absolutely positive.
Speaker:Kim, thank you for demonstrating so well.
Speaker:I did not even think about
Speaker:that, but that is awesome.
Speaker:That is awesome and true.
Speaker:Yes, absentee is...
Speaker:We'll get you back on, Kim.
Speaker:I was looking forward to seeing you
Speaker:again, so we'll get you back on.
Speaker:We definitely will.
Speaker:And just let everybody
Speaker:know, because in America,
Speaker:we have Thanksgiving next week...
Speaker:Not next week, I'm sorry.
Speaker:The week after next week.
Speaker:So next week's Sunday and
Speaker:the following week's Sunday,
Speaker:Pamela and I are taking off for the
Speaker:Thanksgiving break that we have,
Speaker:so to get ready for the holiday and to
Speaker:recoup from the holiday.
Speaker:So we will be back on...
Speaker:I got to look at the date, because I am
Speaker:not good with dates.
Speaker:So we are going to take
Speaker:off the 22nd and the 29th,
Speaker:and we will be back on December 6.
Speaker:December 6, we will be back.
Speaker:So just let everybody know.
Speaker:And then we've got three episodes before
Speaker:we take our break for Christmas
Speaker:and the holidays there.
Speaker:So just let everybody know that.
Speaker:But yes, we are
Speaker:talking about absenteeism.
Speaker:And as I said in the intro, it's a big
Speaker:deal right now for us.
Speaker:Oh, yeah.
Speaker:Because I don't know, do you get the
Speaker:whole week off for Thanksgiving, Pamela?
Speaker:Nope.
Speaker:We only get two days off.
Speaker:We get a half day on Wednesday.
Speaker:And the reason it's a half day is because
Speaker:it's a buyback for our
Speaker:parent-teacher conferences.
Speaker:Otherwise, we'd have
Speaker:a full day Wednesday.
Speaker:And then we get two days
Speaker:off and then we're back.
Speaker:Okay, so...
Speaker:So we get Thursday,
Speaker:Friday, and then the weekend.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Yeah, we...
Speaker:When I was growing up,
Speaker:that's all we ever had.
Speaker:But California does
Speaker:attendance differently.
Speaker:The way that California pays the schools,
Speaker:it's based on kind of
Speaker:like how we get paid.
Speaker:So they give us...
Speaker:We send them the attendance and then they
Speaker:give us the money at the end of the month
Speaker:based on the previous month's attendance.
Speaker:Because schools would lie.
Speaker:Like when I was in Vegas, we lied.
Speaker:We had count day like at
Speaker:the second week of September.
Speaker:And nobody got suspended.
Speaker:Nobody got dropped from school.
Speaker:Any moves that kids did to switch to
Speaker:different districts,
Speaker:none of that was processed till after
Speaker:count day so that we
Speaker:get the maximum amount.
Speaker:And so because of that problem, that's
Speaker:why California went to,
Speaker:if a kid misses more than one class
Speaker:period, they're absent for the day
Speaker:and they don't get paid for
Speaker:that student for that day.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:So we go to that model.
Speaker:So in order to help with that, so schools
Speaker:weren't losing tons of money,
Speaker:we noticed when we gave kids Thursday and
Speaker:Friday off for Thanksgiving,
Speaker:that was not enough.
Speaker:So they would all take
Speaker:off Monday through Friday.
Speaker:So we did that to kind
Speaker:of save us from that.
Speaker:Yeah, interesting.
Speaker:But now what's happening a week
Speaker:apparently is not enough
Speaker:because I have kids who are going to be
Speaker:gone this week,
Speaker:Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.
Speaker:Plus the week after.
Speaker:So I'm like, must be nuts.
Speaker:Give them an inch and they take a mile.
Speaker:Exactly.
Speaker:So has it been this way for a while
Speaker:because COVID and post-COVID,
Speaker:our state, Washington state, kind of took
Speaker:the teeth out of attendance
Speaker:and tardies for a while.
Speaker:And we're just now getting back to, okay,
Speaker:your attendance matters.
Speaker:No, we've been back
Speaker:for a while with that.
Speaker:They did give us some
Speaker:leeway in the beginning.
Speaker:Like maybe the first year or
Speaker:two after, but not this long.
Speaker:Because we have, it's a problem in
Speaker:California with conic absenteeism.
Speaker:And we have this stupid
Speaker:thing that I can't stand.
Speaker:It's called independent study.
Speaker:So what happens is if kids are going to
Speaker:be gone more than two days,
Speaker:and it's really, it's designed to
Speaker:actually help the kids,
Speaker:but it's not really there for the kids.
Speaker:The schools do it because we recoup that
Speaker:absentee money this way.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:So the kids, we have to assign work for
Speaker:them to do while they're gone.
Speaker:And then when they come back, the
Speaker:attendance will send us a little form
Speaker:that we have to fill out how much of the
Speaker:work did they actually complete.
Speaker:And then they have to sign a contract
Speaker:that they're going to do the work, et
Speaker:cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
Speaker:So they have three days to get it in when
Speaker:they come, once they come back.
Speaker:They've got three days once they come
Speaker:back to get it all in.
Speaker:So it's only pre-planned absences?
Speaker:It's got to be pre-planned.
Speaker:Yep.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:Pre-planned.
Speaker:So if they don't tell
Speaker:you, then they don't do this.
Speaker:Nope, they can't.
Speaker:They're all unexcused.
Speaker:Is that a consequence?
Speaker:I have a lot of students go off on
Speaker:vacation and they don't tell me, so.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Well, it's something that's advertised to
Speaker:the parents and
Speaker:everything that you've got.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:It's everywhere.
Speaker:So they kind of know about it.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Because otherwise they're unexcused
Speaker:because California only
Speaker:excuses absence for medical
Speaker:appointments, personal illness, or death
Speaker:of an immediate family member.
Speaker:That is it.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:So anything else that
Speaker:you do is an unexcuse.
Speaker:It's considered skipping school.
Speaker:So that's why they're so strict on this.
Speaker:So we have this work.
Speaker:We got to fill it out.
Speaker:And then based on the percentage, the
Speaker:total percentage of
Speaker:work the kids turned in for
Speaker:classes, we can recoup that much money
Speaker:back from the state.
Speaker:So they do this type of thing.
Speaker:It's like a good idea on paper, but it
Speaker:probably adds a lot to you.
Speaker:Yeah, it does.
Speaker:This school does it much
Speaker:better than my previous schools.
Speaker:It's less work for us.
Speaker:She has a form already filled out and you
Speaker:don't have to sign it manually.
Speaker:It's a spreadsheet and
Speaker:you just type your name in.
Speaker:That means you confirm and
Speaker:it's already set to 100%.
Speaker:And then she's got a dropdown of the
Speaker:different percentages if
Speaker:they didn't do the right amount.
Speaker:So that you can just click the dropdown,
Speaker:type your name in, and you're done.
Speaker:No paperwork to actually fill out where
Speaker:my old one, we used to
Speaker:have to have paperwork.
Speaker:And then we used to have to have a sample
Speaker:of their paperwork and staple it to it to
Speaker:prove the whole thing.
Speaker:We don't have to do all that.
Speaker:It's just a problem because nine out of
Speaker:10 of the kids don't do it.
Speaker:That was my next question was how many of
Speaker:the students will actually do the work?
Speaker:Nine out of 10.
Speaker:They're like, "Well, I was on vacation.
Speaker:I didn't want to do the work."
Speaker:I'm like, "But you were
Speaker:supposed to be in school.
Speaker:We have plenty of vacations.
Speaker:We have a week at Thanksgiving.
Speaker:We have two weeks at Christmas.
Speaker:We have a week in
Speaker:February for Presidents Day.
Speaker:We have a week at spring break."
Speaker:And then you have, I don't know, six or
Speaker:seven weeks in the summertime.
Speaker:There are plenty of times.
Speaker:My parents never took
Speaker:me out for a vacation.
Speaker:This is one of the things that happened
Speaker:post-pandemic is that before
Speaker:parents used to schedule their
Speaker:vacations, "Okay, when is spring break?
Speaker:That's when we're going on vacation."
Speaker:And now they're like, "Oh, well, we can
Speaker:take our kids out of school at any point.
Speaker:And I appreciate that you're missing the
Speaker:lines at Disneyland.
Speaker:I appreciate that the planes are less
Speaker:crowded and everything.
Speaker:But every single parent thinks that,
Speaker:well, that's a generalization.
Speaker:That's hyperbole.
Speaker:There are a lot of parents who are just
Speaker:yanking their kids out
Speaker:all through the school year
Speaker:for vacations.
Speaker:Not for, like, you know,
Speaker:I understand an emergency.
Speaker:I understand medical stuff.
Speaker:But the planned vacations in the middle
Speaker:of the school year, they're difficult.
Speaker:They're long.
Speaker:They're longer than they've ever been.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:I've had it now.
Speaker:I've got two anecdotes, one from this
Speaker:year and one from many
Speaker:years ago, because this
Speaker:happened even before COVID.
Speaker:I had a kid in Vegas.
Speaker:He was a freshman.
Speaker:And I only knew him two
Speaker:days before he went out.
Speaker:I was taking an educational seven-day
Speaker:trip to Washington, D.C.
Speaker:Now they already knew their kid.
Speaker:And the kid did not
Speaker:actually complete eighth grade.
Speaker:He did not have all the credits to
Speaker:complete eighth grade.
Speaker:But it's social promotion, right?
Speaker:So you know your
Speaker:kid's already struggling.
Speaker:So let's take him out at the beginning of
Speaker:the school year where--
Speaker:At the beginning, the crucial time.
Speaker:On the third day.
Speaker:Because we started, like,
Speaker:two days before Labor Day.
Speaker:And then we were off for
Speaker:that Labor Day weekend.
Speaker:And we took that and took
Speaker:whole seven school days.
Speaker:Not seven week-- seven days.
Speaker:Seven school days out.
Speaker:So he comes back and he's too far behind.
Speaker:He can't catch up.
Speaker:He's not the motivated kind.
Speaker:And he failed every
Speaker:single class his freshman year.
Speaker:The parents actually screwed
Speaker:him up for his freshman year.
Speaker:He's now going to be a
Speaker:five-year high schooler.
Speaker:Because--
Speaker:Yeah, super senior.
Speaker:Because they did that.
Speaker:And I'm like, you know your kid.
Speaker:I hope he learns a lot at
Speaker:Washington DC to make up for it.
Speaker:So you maybe--
Speaker:I don't know how much
Speaker:math and English and Spanish.
Speaker:You know, it was just--
Speaker:I was like, what the
Speaker:heck were you thinking?
Speaker:And now look, you
Speaker:sabotaged your kid for--
Speaker:I think it wasn't a wedding.
Speaker:It wasn't a funeral.
Speaker:It was to go to Washington DC.
Speaker:And you could have planned it because
Speaker:Washington DC is not
Speaker:a line at Disneyland.
Speaker:It could have just as easily been
Speaker:planned in the summertime.
Speaker:Just as easily.
Speaker:So that was one.
Speaker:Then we had one this year.
Speaker:We had a parent conference
Speaker:because she's also on a 504
Speaker:plan.
Speaker:So you already know she's struggling
Speaker:with learning issues.
Speaker:And I have nothing against that.
Speaker:No, no.
Speaker:I'm not saying it as a negative thing.
Speaker:I'm just pointing out the picture.
Speaker:Her grandparents wanted to
Speaker:take her to Hawaii for 10 days
Speaker:in the middle of sleep.
Speaker:So they said, oh, we
Speaker:thought that'd be a good idea.
Speaker:So we let her go.
Speaker:OK, and then we had this conference.
Speaker:After she came back, all of her grades
Speaker:dropped down to Cs and Ds.
Speaker:And we don't know what went on.
Speaker:You don't know what went on?
Speaker:Two weeks at our school--
Speaker:two weeks at our school
Speaker:because we're on the block
Speaker:is a month of classes.
Speaker:She missed a month.
Speaker:And it's the foundational skills at the
Speaker:beginning of the year.
Speaker:And now she's stuck right there.
Speaker:I mean, she does her work.
Speaker:Her work was turned in.
Speaker:She did the independence today.
Speaker:She actually did the work.
Speaker:That's good.
Speaker:That's good.
Speaker:But she wasn't there for the instruction.
Speaker:And it was the fundamentals.
Speaker:So both in math and in language, she
Speaker:does not have a lot of the fundamentals.
Speaker:And so she does her work.
Speaker:But she can't do the work to the ability
Speaker:that she might have been
Speaker:able to do the work if she
Speaker:was there for the instruction.
Speaker:And this is why I'm not
Speaker:worried about generative AI
Speaker:because you really need a
Speaker:living, breathing teacher
Speaker:in front of you.
Speaker:I mean, if you're a self-starter,
Speaker:you can get pretty far on your own.
Speaker:But there comes a point
Speaker:when I'm learning language.
Speaker:There comes a point when
Speaker:I need to talk to someone.
Speaker:And generative AI isn't going to do it.
Speaker:And 100 million YouTube
Speaker:videos aren't going to do it.
Speaker:There comes a point when I need to have
Speaker:someone in front of me.
Speaker:Absolutely.
Speaker:And I can speak from that
Speaker:too because as I'm learning
Speaker:Maltese, I do have a tutor.
Speaker:They're not comprehensible input.
Speaker:They don't make the
Speaker:lesson comprehensible.
Speaker:I'm not knocking the tutor at all,
Speaker:not knocking the tutor.
Speaker:It's the way that he's European.
Speaker:He's in France doing the thing.
Speaker:That's the way they do it there.
Speaker:So that's fine.
Speaker:But it's not comprehensible.
Speaker:I don't understand what he's saying.
Speaker:A lot of the times,
Speaker:I've got to pick out words
Speaker:because he's speaking in a natural flow.
Speaker:He's not trying to be comprehensible.
Speaker:So all those things.
Speaker:So I do have a live person tutor.
Speaker:And I need that tutor.
Speaker:But I also back it up
Speaker:with AI because everybody
Speaker:knows I'm a big AI person.
Speaker:I use a lot of stuff.
Speaker:But it cannot replace what he's doing.
Speaker:What do I do?
Speaker:I take our vocabulary.
Speaker:And the vocabulary is every week.
Speaker:It's like 180 vocabulary
Speaker:words every week, every week.
Speaker:And I'm putting them in there.
Speaker:I'm having AI write me
Speaker:stories that are comprehensible
Speaker:for myself to do that.
Speaker:And I have a little app I made for an AI
Speaker:where I copy and paste
Speaker:the story into this app.
Speaker:And then I click Enter.
Speaker:And then all I have to
Speaker:do, if I don't know a word,
Speaker:is click on the word.
Speaker:And it tells you what
Speaker:just that word means.
Speaker:So it makes it through that way.
Speaker:But most--
Speaker:But it's not you how to study.
Speaker:And most of our students
Speaker:who are chronically absent,
Speaker:they don't have the study skills yet.
Speaker:They haven't been in school long enough
Speaker:to learn how to study.
Speaker:And this is one of my problems of
Speaker:in-school suspension, which
Speaker:I was also going to bring
Speaker:up because that's part of,
Speaker:to me, chronic
Speaker:absenteeism is in-school suspension,
Speaker:somebody who's already
Speaker:having a hard time connecting
Speaker:with school, they get
Speaker:yanked out of my class.
Speaker:And they're sitting in a little closet.
Speaker:And I'm supposed to
Speaker:give them worksheets to do.
Speaker:Do you think they're going to do the
Speaker:worksheets on their own?
Speaker:They need to be in my class.
Speaker:They need to feel a
Speaker:connection with school.
Speaker:So I hate in-school suspension so much.
Speaker:Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker:And I was trying to say that the AI is
Speaker:not enough to help me.
Speaker:I need that live person that you said--
Speaker:You need a live person.
Speaker:You need that live person in there.
Speaker:And it may be easy.
Speaker:It's not a real popular
Speaker:language where the AI models
Speaker:know it really, really well.
Speaker:They can do some things, but they can't
Speaker:generate voices in it.
Speaker:Like, I can have AI generate
Speaker:a voice in Spanish or French
Speaker:or Japanese.
Speaker:They don't have enough of a sound sample.
Speaker:So they don't have that in there.
Speaker:So it's a struggle.
Speaker:And I said, you do
Speaker:need that human element.
Speaker:I don't think we can be replaced.
Speaker:Some school districts
Speaker:tried with Rosetta Stone.
Speaker:That did not work.
Speaker:That was a big stink
Speaker:out here in Washington.
Speaker:And I always like to use
Speaker:this example because I bought,
Speaker:at one time, you can get
Speaker:a lifetime access to all
Speaker:of the languages on
Speaker:Rosetta Stone for like $100.
Speaker:They had some kind of special.
Speaker:Back when it was switching from the CDs,
Speaker:DVDs to actual online.
Speaker:So I bought it.
Speaker:And I wanted to see because
Speaker:I like to learn languages.
Speaker:I really want to
Speaker:thought, oh, this might work.
Speaker:Let me try it.
Speaker:And I want to try it not
Speaker:with Spanish, not with French,
Speaker:not with German,
Speaker:anything that's familiar.
Speaker:I went completely out
Speaker:of my way to a language
Speaker:I had no business knowing.
Speaker:So I did Korean.
Speaker:So the first lesson--
Speaker:I went through the first lesson.
Speaker:This is the lesson that
Speaker:they give free always.
Speaker:And it's supposed to
Speaker:sell you on the method.
Speaker:I think that sounds like a Korean too.
Speaker:So and I know nothing
Speaker:about any Asian language.
Speaker:I am completely ignorant,
Speaker:which I got to really pick up
Speaker:because next week we start our new unit
Speaker:in my multicultural.
Speaker:And the language is Korean.
Speaker:Oh, good.
Speaker:OK.
Speaker:So I'll be getting
Speaker:some experience with it.
Speaker:But Korean is a beautiful language to me.
Speaker:And I like the Korean culture.
Speaker:I'm not a K-pop person.
Speaker:But I like the idea of
Speaker:the Korean culture and stuff
Speaker:like that.
Speaker:So I picked that was a
Speaker:language I wanted to pick.
Speaker:So I did that the whole lesson.
Speaker:And I succeeded on the lesson.
Speaker:I got all the green check marks.
Speaker:They don't do any translation.
Speaker:So it's based off the natural method.
Speaker:And this is where--
Speaker:It's Pimsler.
Speaker:It's Pimsler.
Speaker:And Krashen-- well,
Speaker:Pimsler is not visual.
Speaker:You're not supposed to
Speaker:have anything reading.
Speaker:Oh, that's true.
Speaker:But it's not really the natural method
Speaker:because it's just a picture and a word.
Speaker:And the pictures are
Speaker:gorgeous in Rosetta Stone.
Speaker:But they're not particular to the culture
Speaker:that you're studying.
Speaker:Yeah, that's true.
Speaker:For generic pictures.
Speaker:But at the same time, it is the natural--
Speaker:because they don't use
Speaker:any translation, which
Speaker:Blaine and Krashen used to argue about.
Speaker:And then Krashen got put
Speaker:in his place in a nice way.
Speaker:And he realized, oh, crap, translation
Speaker:might be necessary at some point.
Speaker:In a real live situation,
Speaker:Krashen was put on the spot.
Speaker:And he goes, you're right.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:But I went through the whole lesson
Speaker:thinking I was learning
Speaker:about boy, girl, ball, horse,
Speaker:plane--
Speaker:I mean, some random nouns,
Speaker:but at least something concrete.
Speaker:And I succeeded through the whole lesson.
Speaker:Then I went to the Spanish
Speaker:to see what they were actually
Speaker:teaching because I didn't know.
Speaker:Yeah, it was totally different, right?
Speaker:No.
Speaker:It was prepositions.
Speaker:Who starts with prepositions?
Speaker:It was under, on top of, next to.
Speaker:I'm like, what?
Speaker:No textbook has ever
Speaker:started with prepositions.
Speaker:They must have done it
Speaker:differently after the CDs.
Speaker:But yeah, yeah.
Speaker:I'm kind of frustrated
Speaker:with Rosetta Stone's.
Speaker:So I was like, OK, so you
Speaker:didn't give me any context
Speaker:that that's what I
Speaker:was looking for, right?
Speaker:What I thought I was saying
Speaker:was boy and girl and plane
Speaker:and horse.
Speaker:Why did they start with prepositions?
Speaker:That's like novice high at the earliest.
Speaker:And novice--
Speaker:oh my god, the dang prepositions and
Speaker:multis are horrible.
Speaker:But if there's one thing,
Speaker:if you're fluent in language,
Speaker:the one thing that always
Speaker:slips you up is prepositions.
Speaker:Because although
Speaker:there's a literal translation
Speaker:for everyone, a real simple
Speaker:one, they use them differently,
Speaker:like con means with.
Speaker:But we don't always
Speaker:use the same preposition.
Speaker:Because in Spanish, we marry with
Speaker:someone, not to someone.
Speaker:That's the one I always go to also, yeah.
Speaker:And you dream--
Speaker:Japanese also, yeah.
Speaker:And you dream with
Speaker:something, not about something.
Speaker:So you mess up the
Speaker:prepositions because you use the ones
Speaker:that you use in your own language.
Speaker:Well, the multis ones are even worse.
Speaker:So prepositions are hard.
Speaker:And without a context to say, we're
Speaker:prepositions today, I had no clue.
Speaker:That's what I was
Speaker:supposed to be focusing on.
Speaker:So the one the lesson
Speaker:you're supposed to sell me on
Speaker:did not sell me on the whole method.
Speaker:And school districts
Speaker:bought all these programs,
Speaker:all these accesses, and
Speaker:hoped their kids were going
Speaker:to learn the language.
Speaker:And they didn't.
Speaker:Because, yeah, there was a long story.
Speaker:Rosetta Stone was going
Speaker:school to school saying,
Speaker:why don't you lay off your teachers
Speaker:and have a computer lab?
Speaker:But that was messy out here.
Speaker:It was nuts.
Speaker:And so the problem that I have, and I'm
Speaker:sure you have the same thing, is I can
Speaker:give you all the work
Speaker:that we did.
Speaker:But I can't reproduce the instruction.
Speaker:And then I had one parent say, well,
Speaker:can she come in an hour to
Speaker:make up each of those days
Speaker:with you in the morning?
Speaker:And I'm like, I am not going to recreate
Speaker:a class that we did.
Speaker:Every day because you
Speaker:chose to take your child out.
Speaker:I'm not getting paid extra for that.
Speaker:And I'm not trying to be mean or callous.
Speaker:But do you hear what
Speaker:you're asking someone to do?
Speaker:You're like, OK, you work
Speaker:at a fast food restaurant.
Speaker:I am going to be out.
Speaker:Can you work my shift for me without
Speaker:getting paid and your
Speaker:shift so that it gets covered?
Speaker:Uh-huh.
Speaker:It doesn't work that way.
Speaker:And I can't reproduce it.
Speaker:I've not found a valid
Speaker:way to reproduce that.
Speaker:So we all have to do what we've been
Speaker:doing and struggling
Speaker:with, and some kids are
Speaker:better at it than others,
Speaker:is trying to catch them up in class
Speaker:by trying to be as
Speaker:comprehensible as possible
Speaker:and being more
Speaker:comprehensible than we would normally
Speaker:because the other
Speaker:students have all been exposed.
Speaker:They're your barometer student, and you
Speaker:have to differentiate in such a way
Speaker:that the students who've been there
Speaker:aren't getting bored,
Speaker:but the student who's missed everything
Speaker:gets the scaffolding they need.
Speaker:And that's a balancing trick.
Speaker:It is because that's the problem I
Speaker:have because the other
Speaker:kids are like, we were here.
Speaker:We don't need to go over this anymore.
Speaker:And the other kid does need it.
Speaker:And so it is.
Speaker:It's a fine balancing trick, and there's
Speaker:no real easy answer.
Speaker:I know during COVID,
Speaker:right after post-COVID,
Speaker:a lot of kids were--
Speaker:they weren't really monitoring the
Speaker:attendance and the tardies,
Speaker:like you said.
Speaker:So a lot of kids were out, and so they
Speaker:allowed us at the time,
Speaker:but they don't do it
Speaker:now, let us do it anymore,
Speaker:is to record a class.
Speaker:So they could either
Speaker:come in live and do a Zoom.
Speaker:So we opened up a Zoom
Speaker:meeting, and we were in class,
Speaker:so they could at least
Speaker:listen live if they were there,
Speaker:or Zoom would record the meeting,
Speaker:and then we could share it
Speaker:out on our learning platform
Speaker:for them.
Speaker:But that was put in as
Speaker:a MOU in the union thing
Speaker:because that was an extra thing, and you
Speaker:had to be really careful because--
Speaker:frankly, it's more
Speaker:work for us because when
Speaker:you teach to the camera, it's so
Speaker:different than teaching
Speaker:to students in front of you.
Speaker:I would always tell the
Speaker:students, I'd be like, well,
Speaker:you know how you read a
Speaker:book, and you're like,
Speaker:this is a great book, and
Speaker:then you go see the movie,
Speaker:and you're like, why is the
Speaker:movie nothing like the book?
Speaker:It's because teaching in front
Speaker:of actual living human beings
Speaker:is totally different than
Speaker:recording a YouTube video.
Speaker:Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker:Absolutely.
Speaker:Most of us didn't
Speaker:even teach to the camera.
Speaker:We didn't even point it at the board.
Speaker:And we were there because you couldn't
Speaker:have a kid in the video at all.
Speaker:And it was even
Speaker:questionable having their voices,
Speaker:the kids' voices on the
Speaker:video because if they were
Speaker:identifiable, then
Speaker:you're doing the FERPA.
Speaker:So it was a whole thing.
Speaker:But we had an MOU for that first year
Speaker:after that to do that.
Speaker:And then after that,
Speaker:the unions took it out
Speaker:because if something happens to the
Speaker:classroom discipline-wise,
Speaker:things that happen in the classroom-
Speaker:Oh, that's true.
Speaker:I hadn't thought about that.
Speaker:Parents are like, they
Speaker:don't see the context of it.
Speaker:They're only hearing it.
Speaker:And then they make some kind of comment
Speaker:or go the whole length
Speaker:of it, all the things
Speaker:that parents can do.
Speaker:So it was really scary to
Speaker:have that video in the classroom.
Speaker:So I don't have an easy answer.
Speaker:I really don't.
Speaker:In advance, and I think of what I do, and
Speaker:I do, like you said,
Speaker:I work really hard to make
Speaker:my lessons comprehensible
Speaker:and try to use them as
Speaker:my barometer student.
Speaker:I just call them slow
Speaker:processors, my slow processors,
Speaker:so that I can ask them
Speaker:more questions to see
Speaker:if they're with me or not.
Speaker:But other than that, a lot
Speaker:of the burden is on the kids.
Speaker:I mean, I do give them
Speaker:access to digital flashcards
Speaker:and digital games to play online,
Speaker:so they can play those things to help
Speaker:build that foundation.
Speaker:But there's no way for us in
Speaker:comprehensible input
Speaker:to reproduce that class
Speaker:without doing it over again
Speaker:for that student or to record the class.
Speaker:And I forgot to say in our sub week,
Speaker:when we did our sub
Speaker:week, some things I do do,
Speaker:if I know I'm going to be gone and I
Speaker:don't have anything else,
Speaker:I do record one class.
Speaker:So I do it in front of the camera,
Speaker:and then the sub will play it on there.
Speaker:And I can run through all the parts.
Speaker:And so that's really
Speaker:helpful too to do that.
Speaker:But as I said, I'm not going to do that
Speaker:for a kid who's taking a vacation.
Speaker:I'm not doing it for one kid.
Speaker:I'm doing it for my 197 kids that I have.
Speaker:And that's a very different thing
Speaker:because we don't have a textbook to fall
Speaker:back on for them to do it.
Speaker:And even if you do, how much are they
Speaker:going to learn from the textbook?
Speaker:Because if the
Speaker:textbook could teach it alone,
Speaker:then languages could
Speaker:be an independent study.
Speaker:They wouldn't need us.
Speaker:They wouldn't need us.
Speaker:Yeah, textbooks are perfect.
Speaker:And of all the classes, it's like PE,
Speaker:all the classes you can't make up.
Speaker:You can read the novel that
Speaker:you missed in English class.
Speaker:You can read the
Speaker:chapters in history class.
Speaker:You can read the
Speaker:chapters in science class.
Speaker:You can practice all the
Speaker:problems in math class.
Speaker:But like dance and sports and music,
Speaker:you actually have to
Speaker:be there interacting.
Speaker:You have to do it.
Speaker:Yeah, exactly.
Speaker:You need to have the
Speaker:instrument in the hand.
Speaker:You need to get up and run the mile.
Speaker:You need to be using the language.
Speaker:You need to be applying the skills.
Speaker:So other than the
Speaker:students who go on vacation,
Speaker:we've got the students who
Speaker:are absent for other reasons.
Speaker:They either have health issues.
Speaker:And my oldest daughter was like that,
Speaker:very, very sick with Crohn's disease,
Speaker:couldn't work on school
Speaker:because she was in so much pain.
Speaker:We've got students--
Speaker:I have so many students
Speaker:nowadays who have social anxiety
Speaker:to a huge degree.
Speaker:And I don't know if it's
Speaker:just the state of the world
Speaker:or if it's just that we're
Speaker:a little more accepting of,
Speaker:oh, you've got social anxiety.
Speaker:Fine, stay home.
Speaker:Instead of the parents
Speaker:forcing the kids to go to school
Speaker:anyway, those students are already--
Speaker:they're struggling in school already.
Speaker:And there's this
Speaker:spiral of they miss class.
Speaker:And then when they come back, oh my gosh,
Speaker:I have no idea what's going on.
Speaker:Everyone's talking in complete sentences.
Speaker:And I don't know.
Speaker:The effective filter gets really high.
Speaker:And so then the next day, they get
Speaker:another stomach upset.
Speaker:And they don't come back to school again.
Speaker:And it's just this big, huge spiral.
Speaker:And those are the students that I
Speaker:find the hardest to bring back up.
Speaker:Because generally, a student who's
Speaker:going to come to you and say, oh, I'm
Speaker:going on vacation next week.
Speaker:Can I have the work ahead of time?
Speaker:And you're like, there
Speaker:is no work ahead of time
Speaker:because we're making
Speaker:up the story in class.
Speaker:But they're at least-- they're motivated.
Speaker:The other students are either--
Speaker:they don't know how
Speaker:to motivate themselves.
Speaker:They don't know how to
Speaker:access the information.
Speaker:They're too embarrassed to
Speaker:talk to you to begin with.
Speaker:They're in too much pain.
Speaker:They're having-- like, I've got students
Speaker:with cancer treatment.
Speaker:So those students, to put
Speaker:the scaffolding in place
Speaker:is a heck of a lot of work for us.
Speaker:And it's a challenge.
Speaker:And I'll tell you a
Speaker:couple of things that I do.
Speaker:So we have this PAC time,
Speaker:which is our advisory time,
Speaker:where the students who make up work--
Speaker:and they're supposed to be
Speaker:like, oh, I'm struggling in math.
Speaker:I didn't understand
Speaker:the quadratic equation.
Speaker:I'll come in.
Speaker:Honestly, it's the
Speaker:students who were absent.
Speaker:It's always the students
Speaker:who were absent coming in.
Speaker:Now, I teach Spanish and French and
Speaker:Japanese and English
Speaker:this year.
Speaker:My advisory time is absolutely crazy.
Speaker:It is like--
Speaker:And I also heard--
Speaker:Spanish students, would you
Speaker:please come and sit near each
Speaker:other so that I can
Speaker:help you all at one time?
Speaker:I heard they're going to
Speaker:give you math next year.
Speaker:They're going to add math to your thing.
Speaker:Probably.
Speaker:But it is-- I really want this
Speaker:intervention time to work.
Speaker:I can see with my
Speaker:colleagues-- my colleagues,
Speaker:oh, I'm the Algebra 1 teacher.
Speaker:So they get all the Algebra 1
Speaker:students in there at one time.
Speaker:Yay, it's working for you.
Speaker:For me, it is absolutely insane.
Speaker:And so things that I have hit on is, OK,
Speaker:comprehensible input
Speaker:is comprehensible input.
Speaker:I can't give a story
Speaker:to the French students
Speaker:or Spanish students are
Speaker:getting confused because they're
Speaker:trying to work on Spanish
Speaker:stuff and the Japanese students
Speaker:are like, what the
Speaker:heck's going on over there?
Speaker:So I have my two main go-getters for--
Speaker:I've got too many students.
Speaker:I've got 30 students in the classroom.
Speaker:And they're all
Speaker:speaking a different language.
Speaker:I will either say, go grab
Speaker:free voluntary reading book
Speaker:off the shelf.
Speaker:And I want you looking
Speaker:for these things that
Speaker:are grammatical things in
Speaker:our story that we're making up
Speaker:or vocabulary in our story.
Speaker:I guarantee you, any book
Speaker:that you can pull off the shelf
Speaker:is going to have whatever grammar you're
Speaker:working on in class.
Speaker:So that's number one.
Speaker:We talked about that, I think, last time.
Speaker:And the other thing is, I'll often
Speaker:project a funny picture
Speaker:on the board.
Speaker:Those crazy cat pictures
Speaker:where someone took a picture just
Speaker:the wrong time and the cat is yawning
Speaker:and there's a sunset behind and it
Speaker:looks like the cat is breathing fire or
Speaker:something like that.
Speaker:So I'll put a crazy picture on the board.
Speaker:And I'll just say, go
Speaker:grab a sheet of paper.
Speaker:Describe it for me.
Speaker:So it's their quick write.
Speaker:And everybody can do
Speaker:that in whatever language
Speaker:they're studying.
Speaker:I can get the English students on to,
Speaker:like, here's your novel.
Speaker:Go read the great Gatsby or whatever.
Speaker:But--
Speaker:But in my case, the not so great Gatsby.
Speaker:I hate the great Gatsby.
Speaker:Don't tell anybody I hated it so much.
Speaker:I'm so glad I'm not
Speaker:teaching it this year.
Speaker:Scaffolding, you got to think really hard
Speaker:about what scaffolding
Speaker:do the students need.
Speaker:Now, I took the deep dive into Interact.
Speaker:Notebooks three years ago.
Speaker:And I'm really glad I did because I can--
Speaker:the students don't
Speaker:know how to take notes.
Speaker:But with the interactive notebook,
Speaker:I can insist, get out
Speaker:your interactive notebook.
Speaker:You had a page of prepositions.
Speaker:Go to your page of prepositions.
Speaker:You're going to need it for this thing.
Speaker:So if nothing else, I can help them.
Speaker:OK, this is what we're working on.
Speaker:Find a buddy, copy
Speaker:their interactive notebook.
Speaker:Or here, I've printed
Speaker:up the prepositions.
Speaker:Copy an interactive notebook.
Speaker:Draw a doodle next to
Speaker:each one so that you know--
Speaker:memory is visual and spatial.
Speaker:So the more I can get them to draw, the
Speaker:more they'll remember.
Speaker:So making sure that
Speaker:they've got the scaffolds,
Speaker:making sure that they
Speaker:know where in the room
Speaker:to look for all the
Speaker:supports that they need.
Speaker:And then my two generic grab a book
Speaker:or look at the board at that silly
Speaker:picture and do something.
Speaker:That's how I try to get
Speaker:them to at least get back
Speaker:in the swing of things so
Speaker:that when they're in class
Speaker:and we're doing our crazy story, they've
Speaker:got enough support that they can start
Speaker:following along with it.
Speaker:And you mentioned
Speaker:something about the anxiety.
Speaker:And--
Speaker:Yeah, the effective
Speaker:filter gets really high.
Speaker:I think it's partially the
Speaker:COVID and partially parents
Speaker:who really want to--
Speaker:I hate using the word
Speaker:coddle, but that's the best way
Speaker:I can explain it, where
Speaker:they feel bad if they don't--
Speaker:unfortunately, in the United States
Speaker:and many places around the world,
Speaker:mental health is not
Speaker:getting the attention
Speaker:or they don't treat it like a real
Speaker:illness like it really
Speaker:is.
Speaker:If you say you have
Speaker:cancer, you get sympathy.
Speaker:If you've got a mental
Speaker:illness, they're like, get over it.
Speaker:So there's that kind of mentality.
Speaker:But there's also going
Speaker:overboard with it, too,
Speaker:because I have someone
Speaker:who's close to me who
Speaker:suffers from depression and would refuse
Speaker:to go to work at the beginning.
Speaker:And it would extend further longer.
Speaker:And the longer you're out,
Speaker:the easier it is to stay out
Speaker:and harder it is to come back.
Speaker:And this was as an adult
Speaker:and not working with school,
Speaker:so the work didn't pile
Speaker:up that they had to do.
Speaker:It was just getting back to work.
Speaker:But I have a girl right now
Speaker:who took like 2 and 1,000 weeks
Speaker:off before she went on anxiety leave.
Speaker:She's on anxiety leave right now.
Speaker:Because that's spiral.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And then now she's on anxiety leave.
Speaker:She's right now scheduled to
Speaker:come back after Thanksgiving.
Speaker:But she's missed probably
Speaker:a good six weeks of school.
Speaker:And because we're on the
Speaker:block, that's really 12 weeks.
Speaker:That's three months of class.
Speaker:And she's a gate student.
Speaker:So if you don't know what
Speaker:that is, for some of you,
Speaker:it's a gifted and talented.
Speaker:It's how they
Speaker:designate them in California.
Speaker:So she's really intelligent.
Speaker:She can do the work.
Speaker:And then mom emailed us and saying,
Speaker:she's being overwhelmed by the work.
Speaker:Can we limit the amount of work that she
Speaker:needs to do to make up?
Speaker:And I'm like, well,
Speaker:everything that I have in there
Speaker:is not frivolous.
Speaker:It's not.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:She asked every teacher
Speaker:to limit what they do.
Speaker:And I'm like, she goes, can you just
Speaker:limit down to the things
Speaker:that give the most impact
Speaker:for the grade?
Speaker:I go, well, I can do that.
Speaker:No problem.
Speaker:But she's going to
Speaker:miss all the foundational
Speaker:because she wasn't in
Speaker:class for the instruction.
Speaker:And now she's going to miss
Speaker:all the practice activities
Speaker:that would--
Speaker:The practice getting up to--
Speaker:Do those bigger assignments.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And so it's really hard to
Speaker:reproduce that three months.
Speaker:And I know we want to
Speaker:care for our children.
Speaker:We want to care for our students.
Speaker:But in real life, if you let
Speaker:them take the easy road out,
Speaker:or I don't want to say the easy road,
Speaker:take the easier road
Speaker:out by not going to school
Speaker:and giving in to that--
Speaker:I mean, for a short period, maybe.
Speaker:But you need to do what they
Speaker:did because anxiety has always
Speaker:been there, always been there.
Speaker:You know, before COVID, after COVID,
Speaker:I don't think it's any bigger of an issue
Speaker:than it was back in the
Speaker:80s and the 70s and the 60s.
Speaker:I just think we're more aware of it.
Speaker:Absolutely.
Speaker:And so that type of thing.
Speaker:But I don't think you're
Speaker:doing your child any favors
Speaker:by letting them stay home
Speaker:for extended periods of time.
Speaker:Because it's not just
Speaker:about the education,
Speaker:but what happens when
Speaker:they become an adult
Speaker:and then they don't go to work for an
Speaker:extended period of time?
Speaker:How are they going to make-- they've
Speaker:got to find a coping
Speaker:mechanism because there
Speaker:are things you want to do and there are
Speaker:things you have to do.
Speaker:And school and work is
Speaker:something you have to do.
Speaker:So if you give them that out, you're
Speaker:teaching them that that out is OK.
Speaker:And we all have problems.
Speaker:We all have struggles.
Speaker:And we sometimes have
Speaker:to pull up our pants.
Speaker:And I'm not trying to
Speaker:diminish anxiety at all
Speaker:because I live with it.
Speaker:I don't have it.
Speaker:But I live with someone who has it.
Speaker:So it makes a big difference.
Speaker:But I think by coddling that
Speaker:and allowing them to have that,
Speaker:it's easier for them to say, I just
Speaker:don't want to go to school today or I
Speaker:don't want to go to work today.
Speaker:Absolutely.
Speaker:You create a pattern.
Speaker:And then they're not going to learn to--
Speaker:I always like this phrase,
Speaker:that which does not kill you
Speaker:makes you stronger.
Speaker:Makes you stronger.
Speaker:Stronger if you actually face your fears.
Speaker:Go ahead, Pamela.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:No, no, no.
Speaker:I absolutely agree 100%.
Speaker:This was before COVID.
Speaker:I didn't even have her as a student.
Speaker:I had her sister as a student.
Speaker:And suddenly, her father passed away.
Speaker:And so of course, she was grieving.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And after a month of
Speaker:not coming to school,
Speaker:I was talking to the mother.
Speaker:And I was like, look, the big battle
Speaker:is walking through the
Speaker:front doors of school.
Speaker:So I'm going to talk to
Speaker:all the other teachers.
Speaker:And we're not going to grade her.
Speaker:We just need her in the school.
Speaker:And she can always come into my class
Speaker:and sit down and sit in
Speaker:the back of the class.
Speaker:And I'm not going to draw any
Speaker:attention to her whatsoever.
Speaker:But she needs to walk
Speaker:through those front doors.
Speaker:And sure enough, she graduated on time.
Speaker:Her mother was like, boy, if you hadn't
Speaker:made that deal with her,
Speaker:she never would have graduated.
Speaker:She would have just dropped out of school
Speaker:because the grief was huge,
Speaker:losing your father suddenly.
Speaker:And so that's the deal I
Speaker:make with all my students who
Speaker:are suffering from anxiety.
Speaker:I'm like, you've got to come into class.
Speaker:Look, I won't put
Speaker:grades in the grade book.
Speaker:You'll be no count, if
Speaker:they're absent, right?
Speaker:But just be in the classroom.
Speaker:Nobody's going to talk to you.
Speaker:Nobody's going to call on you.
Speaker:Just walk through those front doors.
Speaker:And I've got a student right now who she
Speaker:shouldn't be in French
Speaker:too because she didn't finish French I.
Speaker:But the counselors put her in French II.
Speaker:And I said, well, you know what?
Speaker:I think I'm a good enough
Speaker:teacher where if she comes,
Speaker:I can catch her up.
Speaker:But if I tell her, no, I'm sorry,
Speaker:you've got to go back to French I, that's
Speaker:going to raise her--
Speaker:her anxiety is so high.
Speaker:I was like, OK, I think I'll suck it up.
Speaker:And I'll accept her.
Speaker:She's only been to three classes.
Speaker:And now I'm getting all the emails of--
Speaker:here we are in November.
Speaker:And I'm getting the
Speaker:emails from the mother saying,
Speaker:what can you not count?
Speaker:And I'm like, well, I gave her homework
Speaker:knowing that she wasn't
Speaker:going to come to school.
Speaker:And she's done none of the homework.
Speaker:So there's no--
Speaker:I don't want to tell the mother this.
Speaker:There's no way she can catch up because I
Speaker:want that student to
Speaker:walk through the front door.
Speaker:And so now the
Speaker:counselors are like, OK, we'll
Speaker:bring her back from math only.
Speaker:And then when she gets used to math,
Speaker:we'll add on English.
Speaker:But of course, language
Speaker:is the lowest on the table.
Speaker:So she's probably not
Speaker:going to come back to my class.
Speaker:But it's walking through the front door.
Speaker:That is their first test.
Speaker:And that should be our
Speaker:first priority as teachers,
Speaker:is they're not going to
Speaker:be successful in your class
Speaker:if they're not there.
Speaker:Just get them through that front door.
Speaker:And I'm going to give a
Speaker:personal story to happen to me.
Speaker:In seventh or eighth grade, I don't
Speaker:remember exactly what--
Speaker:because I don't suffer from anxiety.
Speaker:I don't have that issue.
Speaker:But I didn't even know
Speaker:what a panic attack was.
Speaker:And I didn't even know
Speaker:that I had had them in seventh
Speaker:or eighth grade, whatever grade it was.
Speaker:Yeah, they didn't talk
Speaker:about them back in the 80s.
Speaker:So I had no idea.
Speaker:But my PE teacher at the time--
Speaker:we were in a small school.
Speaker:So not only was he my PE teacher,
Speaker:but also my geography teacher.
Speaker:And I had a paper route.
Speaker:And he was on my paper route.
Speaker:So I'm not going to mention his name
Speaker:because he was a good guy.
Speaker:But he was one of
Speaker:those old-fashioned, tough,
Speaker:suck-it-up kind of teachers.
Speaker:And I don't know why
Speaker:they ask high school--
Speaker:I mean, it was middle
Speaker:school-- middle school boys
Speaker:to jump rope, because we don't have the
Speaker:coordination for that.
Speaker:And we had to do this
Speaker:thing called tapioca or karaoke
Speaker:or something-- I don't
Speaker:know, something weird name,
Speaker:where you have to put one foot in front,
Speaker:and then you alternate
Speaker:the other foot in front
Speaker:and jump rope at the same time.
Speaker:OK, I couldn't jump rope normally.
Speaker:I was not one of those girls on the--
Speaker:This is really a sample of laddering.
Speaker:You have to build up
Speaker:the foundational skills
Speaker:before you can go to the big stuff.
Speaker:I mean, girls could do
Speaker:it because they had--
Speaker:on the playground in elementary school,
Speaker:they played those little jump rope games.
Speaker:That was not me.
Speaker:Sexism, the boys are not allowed to do
Speaker:that for some reason,
Speaker:even though they're fun.
Speaker:So anyway, we did not do that.
Speaker:So what happened is the jump
Speaker:rope wrapped around my legs.
Speaker:Oh, no.
Speaker:And then I pulled, you
Speaker:know, when you pull it up.
Speaker:And so I fell.
Speaker:And I sprained my--
Speaker:You pulled yourself up
Speaker:by your own bootstraps.
Speaker:Yeah, exactly.
Speaker:And I sprained my ankle really bad.
Speaker:So after that calisthenics that we did,
Speaker:then we were supposed to--
Speaker:we were playing volleyball.
Speaker:And I was limping.
Speaker:And he goes, if you're
Speaker:going to limp like that,
Speaker:go shower and come back and sit down,
Speaker:dress up and sit down
Speaker:on the bleachers.
Speaker:So I'm like, OK.
Speaker:So I went and sat down on the bleachers.
Speaker:And then I'm going to my next class.
Speaker:And my next class was math.
Speaker:And it was the last class before lunch.
Speaker:So I go into math.
Speaker:He goes, make sure you elevate that foot.
Speaker:But he's yelling at me.
Speaker:And he's a big muscular guy.
Speaker:And he's yelling at me.
Speaker:So I'm like, OK.
Speaker:So I elevate my foot in math class.
Speaker:But it's still swelled up.
Speaker:And so I'm trying to go to lunch.
Speaker:And I got my books in my hand.
Speaker:Because we carried our books.
Speaker:We didn't have backpacks back then.
Speaker:You carried your books.
Speaker:And I'm limping.
Speaker:And my English teacher sees me.
Speaker:And he's helping me to the lunchroom.
Speaker:My math teacher comes out, sees this,
Speaker:and says, if you're going to be a wimp
Speaker:about this, go home.
Speaker:And drags me from my math teacher.
Speaker:And takes me to the office.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:So I go in.
Speaker:We should coddle kids.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:We should not name call them.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:So he called me in there.
Speaker:And he forced me in the office.
Speaker:They called my parents.
Speaker:And come pick me up.
Speaker:So I went to the doctor.
Speaker:And the doctor said, you
Speaker:have a really bad sprain.
Speaker:He goes, it would have
Speaker:been better if you broke it.
Speaker:But you did.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:So they didn't give you boots back then.
Speaker:They didn't give you crutches back then.
Speaker:No.
Speaker:But it wasn't a break.
Speaker:So they didn't cast it either.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:And my foot was a balloon.
Speaker:And it was bad.
Speaker:So I had panic attacks going
Speaker:into PE for the rest of school
Speaker:year.
Speaker:It wasn't I didn't like.
Speaker:And I didn't even know what it was.
Speaker:But I had such anxiety
Speaker:about going into that class
Speaker:all the time that I would
Speaker:freak out going into that class.
Speaker:I would freak out in that class.
Speaker:And then I would leave out.
Speaker:And so I know that
Speaker:that anxiety can be there.
Speaker:And it can be strong.
Speaker:But I didn't tell
Speaker:anybody about that anxiety.
Speaker:I didn't even know that's what it was.
Speaker:I didn't know why I had that feeling.
Speaker:It was the 80s.
Speaker:Nobody talked about anything.
Speaker:But I think that if my parents had
Speaker:said he needs to be
Speaker:pulled out of that class, PE,
Speaker:that I would probably never
Speaker:have gone back to PE ever.
Speaker:Because I would not
Speaker:associate it with that class
Speaker:and that period.
Speaker:I would have
Speaker:generalized it to PE in general.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And I faced the fears.
Speaker:I went in every day.
Speaker:I had the anxiety.
Speaker:I had the sweats.
Speaker:I had the palpitations.
Speaker:I faced it each time.
Speaker:And I made it through.
Speaker:And I think I'm better off
Speaker:for having made it through
Speaker:at that time.
Speaker:So I can see both ends of it.
Speaker:But I think that, like you
Speaker:said, getting them in the door
Speaker:is a really big thing.
Speaker:That's the main thing.
Speaker:And we can reduce the workload.
Speaker:But there's also consequences for
Speaker:reducing the workload too.
Speaker:Whether they're absent
Speaker:for true medical issues
Speaker:or they're absent for vacations, there's
Speaker:sacrifices that the parents are going
Speaker:to have to actually
Speaker:understand that if school could
Speaker:be done at a distance, then you wouldn't
Speaker:have to send your kids to school.
Speaker:And you wouldn't have teachers.
Speaker:So there is a reason why we are there.
Speaker:And so we can work
Speaker:really hard with your kids
Speaker:to try to get them to
Speaker:where they need to be.
Speaker:But if they're not in
Speaker:school, it's going to be difficult.
Speaker:And we have to compromise
Speaker:both on the teacher side
Speaker:and the student-parent side to get them
Speaker:where they need to be.
Speaker:And for some kids, it's
Speaker:going to be a more difficult hill
Speaker:than for others.
Speaker:There are some kids who
Speaker:can catch right back up.
Speaker:And there are other kids
Speaker:who may never catch up.
Speaker:But like you said, we don't want to say
Speaker:that it's impossible at this point.
Speaker:Because you want to give them some hope.
Speaker:But--
Speaker:I got into teaching
Speaker:because I wanted to teach, right?
Speaker:Exactly.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:I don't ever want to
Speaker:slam a student and say,
Speaker:no, you can't do this.
Speaker:I want to--
Speaker:I want to be the person who
Speaker:believes in them when they
Speaker:don't believe in themselves.
Speaker:Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker:And a lot of the students--
Speaker:I would say 95% of the students with
Speaker:chronic absenteeism,
Speaker:they're struggling somehow.
Speaker:OK?
Speaker:They either have a home
Speaker:that's not supportive,
Speaker:or they have health
Speaker:issues, or they have anxiety,
Speaker:or they have some--
Speaker:they're just wired differently.
Speaker:And part of our job as
Speaker:teachers is to figure out
Speaker:how they're wired, how to reach them,
Speaker:how to differentiate for them.
Speaker:It's certainly not
Speaker:fair to their classmates
Speaker:when you have to slow the
Speaker:class down for one person.
Speaker:So the question is how
Speaker:to give them the support
Speaker:that they need in that very moment
Speaker:without sacrificing all
Speaker:the wonderful things you
Speaker:had planned for your class.
Speaker:So let's move it to some concrete,
Speaker:because we've been talking
Speaker:all about the hypotheticals
Speaker:and the issues with it.
Speaker:What do you do other than make your class
Speaker:more comprehensible?
Speaker:Is there something else that
Speaker:you give them or activities
Speaker:that you have them do to
Speaker:help them get caught up?
Speaker:Well, I've got all my
Speaker:scaffolding with the--
Speaker:I don't have room for word walls,
Speaker:because each wall is
Speaker:a different language.
Speaker:But I do have posters up
Speaker:everywhere as much as I can.
Speaker:And I've got chat mats
Speaker:that I will pass out.
Speaker:But now that I'm using
Speaker:the interactive notebooks,
Speaker:I want the students to
Speaker:copy down the chat mat
Speaker:into their interactive notebook.
Speaker:And so sometimes it's just
Speaker:a notebook check for me of,
Speaker:look, do you have the
Speaker:flippy book with the conjugations
Speaker:for Tenere?
Speaker:OK, you don't have it.
Speaker:Here's paper and scissors.
Speaker:You're going to cut it out.
Speaker:I'll be right back.
Speaker:Oh, look here on the wall.
Speaker:This is Tenere.
Speaker:I want you to copy it down.
Speaker:You know, that kind of stuff.
Speaker:Yeah, so it's mostly for me.
Speaker:It's the scaffolding.
Speaker:And it's making
Speaker:wherever we are in the story,
Speaker:whatever we're doing in class, making
Speaker:that very comprehensible
Speaker:so that they can catch up
Speaker:if they're paying attention.
Speaker:There's a lot of choral repetition,
Speaker:so they're getting that.
Speaker:They're getting
Speaker:pronunciation practice and stuff.
Speaker:There's the rejoinders,
Speaker:which they can use anyway.
Speaker:So I used to have Duolingo as homework,
Speaker:because my feeling is you
Speaker:need to look at the language one
Speaker:time outside of class.
Speaker:And Duolingo was very easy to grade,
Speaker:very supportive of teachers.
Speaker:They were a great company at one time.
Speaker:And then over the summer,
Speaker:they basically said, no,
Speaker:we don't want to
Speaker:support teachers anymore.
Speaker:We really want all your
Speaker:students paying for Duolingo Plus.
Speaker:And I'm like, no, forget that.
Speaker:So I've been trying to recreate Duolingo.
Speaker:I think they were sold.
Speaker:And then they got bought.
Speaker:I think that's what happened.
Speaker:No, they're not bought.
Speaker:But they did have their IPO.
Speaker:They had their public buyout.
Speaker:And now everything's bottom line.
Speaker:Just like, I mean, it's--
Speaker:can I say it?
Speaker:It's like a notification,
Speaker:just like everything else.
Speaker:So my goal has been, how
Speaker:do I recreate this five
Speaker:minutes of homework at
Speaker:home, where the students can
Speaker:get quick targeted feedback?
Speaker:They can practice
Speaker:whatever we did in class.
Speaker:It's a lot of work for me.
Speaker:But I think it's good for the students.
Speaker:I've been trying to recreate it using
Speaker:a combination of BlueKit
Speaker:and Wayground and Roxam.
Speaker:And so the students who are absent,
Speaker:they can be doing that at home.
Speaker:And if they're not doing that at home,
Speaker:then that's on you, kid,
Speaker:because that was your practice
Speaker:so that you had practice for
Speaker:what we did in class that day.
Speaker:And you didn't do it at home.
Speaker:If you were at home
Speaker:and didn't know anything,
Speaker:you would at least hear the words.
Speaker:You'd at least know
Speaker:that we were, oh, we're
Speaker:working on prepositions
Speaker:today, you know, or whatever.
Speaker:They would at least get
Speaker:some exposure to that.
Speaker:Because we know that it takes--
Speaker:Susie Pepper Rollins says it takes
Speaker:7 to 20 times of hearing
Speaker:a word before it's yours.
Speaker:I think for world
Speaker:language, it's 7 to 50 times.
Speaker:I think it's a little even
Speaker:more than that for some words.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:The students need that
Speaker:contact with the language.
Speaker:And so getting them that
Speaker:contact with the language concrete
Speaker:stuff, read a book.
Speaker:If nothing else, you
Speaker:can be reading a book.
Speaker:You can watch a YouTube
Speaker:video in the target language
Speaker:of nothing else.
Speaker:But then you have to
Speaker:give me some evidence
Speaker:that you did that on your own time.
Speaker:So I'll have them do a quick write,
Speaker:or I'll have them
Speaker:explain the plot or whatever.
Speaker:So those are some concrete things
Speaker:I do to catch students up.
Speaker:But it's tricky when your
Speaker:curriculum is kind of organic
Speaker:and you're like, oh, I
Speaker:wasn't expecting to talk about--
Speaker:oh, the students were
Speaker:planning a birthday party
Speaker:for one of the classmates.
Speaker:They were going to have the cake.
Speaker:And the cake's candles
Speaker:were made of baguettes.
Speaker:And the baguettes were on fire.
Speaker:And the whole birthday party was going
Speaker:to be held in the bathroom of Home Depot.
Speaker:It was like, I wasn't expecting to teach
Speaker:some of those words.
Speaker:But that's the way the story went.
Speaker:And so in those words,
Speaker:those weren't the main words.
Speaker:But the student might
Speaker:be a little confused
Speaker:when they come back in.
Speaker:But we've got the drawings on the boards.
Speaker:And we've got the students acting it out.
Speaker:Hopefully, they can
Speaker:kind of pick up the gist.
Speaker:I don't know.
Speaker:A couple of things.
Speaker:I want to mention one thing.
Speaker:We forgot one.
Speaker:One category.
Speaker:We've got the kids who are
Speaker:sick and can't help but being out.
Speaker:We got the vacation kids.
Speaker:But the other one that irritates--
Speaker:this one irritates the
Speaker:heck out of me is athletics.
Speaker:Oh, there's a lot of athletics.
Speaker:That's true.
Speaker:And some of them, they
Speaker:make these tournaments.
Speaker:Now, when I was a kid,
Speaker:the all-day tournaments
Speaker:were held on Saturdays.
Speaker:But now, they're
Speaker:doing them on school days.
Speaker:So the kids are missing
Speaker:an entire day of school
Speaker:because they're in cross-country.
Speaker:So that really frustrates me.
Speaker:My one school did it wonderfully.
Speaker:They gave kids who were in--
Speaker:who were in after-school sports PE
Speaker:during the last period of the day.
Speaker:Oh, so they could get on
Speaker:the bus when they needed to.
Speaker:So when they had to get
Speaker:on the bus to go to travel,
Speaker:they were missing PE.
Speaker:Guess what?
Speaker:They were getting PE anyway because
Speaker:they're doing sports.
Speaker:So that worked out really well.
Speaker:They made them do that.
Speaker:So scheduling-wise, and
Speaker:that really, really helped.
Speaker:Other kids, they find out--
Speaker:like, I have a girl this
Speaker:year, and I had a kid a couple
Speaker:of years ago, who realized,
Speaker:oh, yeah, I cannot keep missing
Speaker:Spanish class.
Speaker:I'm falling way behind.
Speaker:And so they get a schedule change to be--
Speaker:Spanish class to be earlier in the day.
Speaker:So-- and I know some schools
Speaker:have done reverse schedules.
Speaker:So one day, it'll be
Speaker:periods one through six in order,
Speaker:and the next day, it'll
Speaker:be period six through one,
Speaker:and you end with one.
Speaker:So that it's not the same
Speaker:class, but that doesn't really
Speaker:help either that much because
Speaker:it's always either period one
Speaker:or period six.
Speaker:Who gets the hit?
Speaker:It's always--
Speaker:Yeah, that's true.
Speaker:So it's better than having
Speaker:it always the same class.
Speaker:Generally, the students who are involved
Speaker:in athletics or music,
Speaker:we've got a lot of
Speaker:music competitions going on.
Speaker:We've got TSA stuff.
Speaker:We've got FBLA competitions.
Speaker:We've got DECA competitions.
Speaker:Generally, those students are the ones
Speaker:who will come to you beforehand saying,
Speaker:I'm going to miss next Thursday.
Speaker:What do I need to do?
Speaker:Yeah, they do.
Speaker:And so at least--
Speaker:even if you're like, I have no idea,
Speaker:you can at least say, give me a day,
Speaker:and I'll get back to you tomorrow.
Speaker:Yeah, it's like--
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:I mean, that's fine,
Speaker:but it's the instruction.
Speaker:And that's my big thing with CI.
Speaker:You're missing the instruction.
Speaker:And I explain it to parents like this.
Speaker:If you have an infant and you're trying
Speaker:to teach them the
Speaker:language because you're talking,
Speaker:it's like not talking
Speaker:to your infant for--
Speaker:not interacting with your
Speaker:infant for a whole week.
Speaker:You can't make that up.
Speaker:There are going to be a
Speaker:week delayed after that.
Speaker:No matter what you do,
Speaker:they're going to be a week delayed.
Speaker:And an example I have with my nephew--
Speaker:my nephew is not deaf, not by
Speaker:any stretch of an imagination.
Speaker:But when he was a baby,
Speaker:he was delayed in speaking,
Speaker:and they didn't know exactly why.
Speaker:They determined it was
Speaker:something with his ears
Speaker:that he had earaches or something there,
Speaker:and they put tubes in his ears.
Speaker:Oh, yeah, yeah, the shunted skin.
Speaker:And then he could hear much better,
Speaker:and his language skills
Speaker:developed much more quickly
Speaker:because of that, because he
Speaker:wasn't getting that input.
Speaker:And I can't reproduce that.
Speaker:Which brings me to what I
Speaker:sometimes do for my kids
Speaker:to help them along the way.
Speaker:And I don't have a
Speaker:resource in all the languages.
Speaker:I just know Alisa Yael for French,
Speaker:and I use Dreaming Spanish for Spanish
Speaker:because they have videos
Speaker:that are free on YouTube
Speaker:that are graduated,
Speaker:meaning that they have them,
Speaker:and they're leveled, that kids can go,
Speaker:and do they cover the exact vocabulary?
Speaker:Not necessarily, but they're getting
Speaker:comprehensible input.
Speaker:Yeah, they just need,
Speaker:they need the rhythm
Speaker:of the language, right?
Speaker:They need to hear the
Speaker:cadence of the language.
Speaker:Sometimes that's enough for me.
Speaker:It's like, okay, you had
Speaker:some contact with the language.
Speaker:Good, yeah.
Speaker:And I could assign those,
Speaker:and then I could come
Speaker:up with 10 questions
Speaker:that assess whether they understood
Speaker:what was going on in those,
Speaker:and give them something like that.
Speaker:So they're hearing the language.
Speaker:They're not just doing a worksheet.
Speaker:That's my main go-to,
Speaker:because it really doesn't
Speaker:take much more effort on my part.
Speaker:And as you build this,
Speaker:you have a library of question banks
Speaker:that you can use for these videos
Speaker:that you keep over the years and go,
Speaker:"Oh, I got one already for that one.
Speaker:Let me go ahead and assign this."
Speaker:The other thing, which
Speaker:I started back in COVID,
Speaker:and I have a
Speaker:collection of them from COVID,
Speaker:that I recorded,
Speaker:because I recorded lessons,
Speaker:because when we first went out on COVID,
Speaker:it was asynchronous.
Speaker:It was not synchronous.
Speaker:So I made a
Speaker:recording, and they watched it.
Speaker:So I did movie talks.
Speaker:So I did my movie talk,
Speaker:and I would act like the kids were there.
Speaker:I would ask my questions like,
Speaker:"Is there a dog or is there a cat?"
Speaker:I wait for them to answer.
Speaker:They go, "That's right. It's a dog."
Speaker:Is the dog.
Speaker:You're right.
Speaker:There's clues for Dora the Explorer.
Speaker:Yeah, I think we all did that.
Speaker:So I recorded, they've
Speaker:got the slides up there.
Speaker:They've got key phrases up there.
Speaker:So I've got quite a
Speaker:few of those recorded.
Speaker:And whenever I have an extra time,
Speaker:I'll go and I'll record a new one.
Speaker:So I have a collection of these
Speaker:that I can also assign kids to.
Speaker:So they're hearing the language.
Speaker:Is it the exact
Speaker:language that we are doing?
Speaker:No, it's not.
Speaker:But it's comprehensible input.
Speaker:And if you are truly doing untargeted,
Speaker:which is what I try to do.
Speaker:I mean, I have to target
Speaker:the vocabulary in the chapter,
Speaker:but my goal is really the sweet 16.
Speaker:And you can use any
Speaker:video to teach the sweet 16.
Speaker:Exactly.
Speaker:It doesn't, and I can adapt any video
Speaker:to teach family if I needed to.
Speaker:But they're getting the
Speaker:heart of the language that way.
Speaker:And so that's a way to help them
Speaker:stay a little bit more comprehensible.
Speaker:And you can even do it where you use,
Speaker:I always forget,
Speaker:because the name does
Speaker:not match the activity.
Speaker:Ed, you, Ed puzzle.
Speaker:Ed puzzle, yeah.
Speaker:That, can you please get on with a name
Speaker:that actually tells what you do,
Speaker:because you think they're
Speaker:making puzzles with this, right?
Speaker:Educational puzzles.
Speaker:But that's not gonna do, it's videos.
Speaker:But my formative does it too,
Speaker:where you can put a video in,
Speaker:stop the video at a certain point,
Speaker:and they can't go forward in the video
Speaker:until they answer the questions.
Speaker:So I can start and stop
Speaker:the video as appropriate
Speaker:in the video to ask the questions
Speaker:just like I would in class.
Speaker:Yeah, Wigra does that too.
Speaker:And so I can do that,
Speaker:and I can have,
Speaker:I can do my slide deck for that,
Speaker:and I can teach from that,
Speaker:and then show them the video at the end.
Speaker:And it works really, really well.
Speaker:So that's another thing that I will do,
Speaker:because just doing the
Speaker:same things that my kids did
Speaker:in class is not gonna help them,
Speaker:because they got the instruction for them
Speaker:to be successful on those activities.
Speaker:So they just keep saying,
Speaker:give me the makeup work.
Speaker:Well, the makeup work is
Speaker:actually being in class.
Speaker:That's where the work really came in.
Speaker:The stuff that you're asking for
Speaker:is just the evidence that you learned
Speaker:what we did in class.
Speaker:Yeah, yep.
Speaker:So that's what makes,
Speaker:oh, we got a little, did you see?
Speaker:No, do we have a?
Speaker:We have some here.
Speaker:Says, I'm gonna butcher
Speaker:how this is pronounced.
Speaker:I hope I said that right.
Speaker:Pam and Scott, thank you
Speaker:for this amazing conversation.
Speaker:I have been typing notes all along.
Speaker:I'm sending them to Scott via email.
Speaker:Awesome, awesome, awesome.
Speaker:I'll share them with Pamela.
Speaker:Awesome, glad to have you here.
Speaker:Yeah, yay.
Speaker:Oh, this is?
Speaker:Yes, Blakey, thank you
Speaker:for listening with us.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Glad to have you with us.
Speaker:We haven't talked about my pet peeve.
Speaker:Okay, go ahead.
Speaker:You've already talked
Speaker:about your pet peeve.
Speaker:I know we're over time already,
Speaker:but my pet peeve is the
Speaker:student who's missed a quiz.
Speaker:Oh, can I make up the
Speaker:quiz when we're done with,
Speaker:if I finish all the
Speaker:working class quickly?
Speaker:I'm like, the working
Speaker:class is the whole class.
Speaker:It's not like I'm
Speaker:sitting you in the corner,
Speaker:work on this, and when
Speaker:you're done, you can do this.
Speaker:The whole class is a
Speaker:conversation, a game, a project.
Speaker:We are applying the language skills.
Speaker:There is no downtime in my class.
Speaker:So no, you cannot make up
Speaker:the test during class time.
Speaker:Oh, I know.
Speaker:You miss class, you come in before
Speaker:school, after school,
Speaker:or during our intervention time.
Speaker:Oh, this is what's-- That's my pet peeve.
Speaker:And I have a pet peeve
Speaker:that's very similar to that.
Speaker:I usually give about 10
Speaker:minutes to do our practices.
Speaker:So it's a listening and reading practice.
Speaker:I usually group those together.
Speaker:And the reading practice is just
Speaker:answering the questions
Speaker:about the reading that we just did.
Speaker:I did with them, right?
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:And the text is there
Speaker:so they can reread it
Speaker:as needed to answer the questions.
Speaker:The listening is a new thing,
Speaker:but it shouldn't take more
Speaker:than 10 minutes to do both.
Speaker:But I give it, I say
Speaker:if you don't finish it,
Speaker:you got it for homework.
Speaker:And then speaking and writing practice,
Speaker:I give them only three questions.
Speaker:Partly because I don't
Speaker:wanna overwhelm them,
Speaker:but partly because I don't wanna grade 10
Speaker:speaking 197 times.
Speaker:So I'll do, and I'll break it up.
Speaker:There'll be one day I'll be speaking
Speaker:and one day I'll be writing.
Speaker:And if they don't finish,
Speaker:it should take less than
Speaker:five minutes, if you know.
Speaker:It means it's really simple things like,
Speaker:we're working on school supplies,
Speaker:what's in your backpack?
Speaker:Or the question that
Speaker:got already stuck on,
Speaker:what's on the ceiling?
Speaker:Lights, because that was
Speaker:a vocab word in our thing.
Speaker:So you just have to answer the question.
Speaker:They're not hard.
Speaker:So I say it's due by
Speaker:the end of the night,
Speaker:by midnight of the night,
Speaker:you get it done if you don't finish it.
Speaker:I don't mark it late,
Speaker:but then I grade it the next day,
Speaker:whoever turned it in by midnight,
Speaker:I'll get graded that next morning.
Speaker:But then I have kids who they go,
Speaker:I'm not gonna work on it right now.
Speaker:I'm like, why not?
Speaker:You've got time to finish it.
Speaker:I'll just do it at home.
Speaker:Then they forget to do it at home.
Speaker:And they come into class and I go,
Speaker:oh, remember all those kids who said
Speaker:they're gonna do it at
Speaker:home tonight and didn't?
Speaker:Well, and they're like,
Speaker:so then they're trying
Speaker:to do it during class,
Speaker:during the instruction.
Speaker:That irritates me.
Speaker:I'm like, I gave you time.
Speaker:You chose to just sit
Speaker:and squander that time.
Speaker:Me, when I was a kid,
Speaker:I don't wanna have homework.
Speaker:So if your teacher gave me time,
Speaker:I was using it.
Speaker:We're gonna do it.
Speaker:I was gonna do it
Speaker:because I don't want
Speaker:that thing after school.
Speaker:And then you didn't do it
Speaker:when you said you were gonna do it.
Speaker:And now you wanna use
Speaker:class time to do it,
Speaker:which I gave you the first time to do.
Speaker:So what's the
Speaker:difference between now and then?
Speaker:That frustrates me.
Speaker:So yes, I hear you.
Speaker:I hear you.
Speaker:I hear you absolutely.
Speaker:So I'm gonna say something else here.
Speaker:What do we have here?
Speaker:So we talked about what we do.
Speaker:And let's go back and reiterate
Speaker:because this is one of the
Speaker:last talking points that we had,
Speaker:that we do need to have compassion.
Speaker:Oh, absolutely.
Speaker:We absolutely need to do.
Speaker:I don't know if we need
Speaker:to have as much compassion
Speaker:as allowing a kid to
Speaker:miss months worth of school
Speaker:and expect them to be able to catch up
Speaker:in that kind of thing.
Speaker:I think we have to
Speaker:temper, even as parents,
Speaker:compassion with, we all
Speaker:gotta do things we don't wanna do
Speaker:and we gotta get up and face those fears.
Speaker:So sometimes staying out for whatever.
Speaker:Because even if
Speaker:you're, let's say you're sick
Speaker:for a physical and not a mental issue.
Speaker:It just went out, you know, and I'm sick,
Speaker:like I was sick with
Speaker:norovirus many years ago before COVID
Speaker:and I was out for a week.
Speaker:It's so much easier to stay home
Speaker:even when you're feeling
Speaker:better than to go back.
Speaker:It is.
Speaker:Well, and COVID taught us,
Speaker:if you're sick, stay home.
Speaker:Yeah, if you're sick, stay home.
Speaker:Right, yeah.
Speaker:But even when I was
Speaker:better and I could go back,
Speaker:I was like, oh, I like dreading that,
Speaker:getting back into the pattern and stuff
Speaker:and all the work that
Speaker:you gotta catch up on.
Speaker:I get it, I get it.
Speaker:But if I didn't do that, I'd
Speaker:still be out now years later.
Speaker:So there's gotta be a point.
Speaker:But we wanna be
Speaker:compassionate up to a point.
Speaker:We wanna be understanding.
Speaker:We wanna give them hope.
Speaker:And one of the things I do,
Speaker:and we didn't talk about this,
Speaker:and it has nothing to
Speaker:do with catching up,
Speaker:but I have postcards in my classroom.
Speaker:I have blank postcards.
Speaker:I buy them off Amazon.
Speaker:They have different sayings on them.
Speaker:And one of them is, I miss you.
Speaker:So whenever a kid is
Speaker:absent for three days or more,
Speaker:I pre-write it. Send the page right home.
Speaker:I will pre-write.
Speaker:I don't know when they're coming back,
Speaker:but I will have the card
Speaker:ready with their name on it
Speaker:and a little personal
Speaker:note that I wrote in there
Speaker:about them and how I
Speaker:missed them and such and such.
Speaker:I'm so, if I don't
Speaker:know why they were gone,
Speaker:I go, I hope you're okay.
Speaker:If there's anything I can do to help you,
Speaker:please let me know because as a person,
Speaker:I want to care for them as a person.
Speaker:So I'll give them that.
Speaker:I usually give them candy with that.
Speaker:And I do it for lots of
Speaker:things, not just for absentees.
Speaker:I give them something,
Speaker:a change in behavior.
Speaker:I want to put it on there.
Speaker:Or if I see even a negative behavior,
Speaker:I'm noticing you've been
Speaker:sleeping in class a lot lately.
Speaker:Is there something I can help you with
Speaker:or is there something going on or
Speaker:something like that?
Speaker:I give them all these different--
Speaker:That's a good way to have the private conversation.
Speaker:Exactly.
Speaker:And I just pass out the cards
Speaker:and the kids don't know
Speaker:if it's a positive card
Speaker:or a negative card I'm giving to the kid.
Speaker:It's just a card.
Speaker:And so that will help and
Speaker:also helps reduce the anxiety.
Speaker:It lets them know that we do care.
Speaker:And I do care about my students.
Speaker:I do care about my anxiety students.
Speaker:I worry about them,
Speaker:but I also worry about
Speaker:the long-term effects
Speaker:of the parent not
Speaker:wanting to fight with the kid
Speaker:and letting them stay home.
Speaker:Or the parent is like,
Speaker:"My kid doesn't want to
Speaker:get up in the morning.
Speaker:So I'm going to let him
Speaker:come in only the second period
Speaker:and after first period all the time."
Speaker:Because you don't understand
Speaker:my child is hard to wake up.
Speaker:I'm like, "That is not a new problem.
Speaker:That has been a problem of ages.
Speaker:And there are sometimes
Speaker:you've got to be the parent
Speaker:and not the friend."
Speaker:Yeah, you can't be the friend.
Speaker:So I would say there is a huge difference
Speaker:between compassion and rescuing.
Speaker:Because there is--
Speaker:Thank you.
Speaker:That's the good word I want.
Speaker:That's kind of what I was trying to say.
Speaker:And you said it much
Speaker:more eloquently than I.
Speaker:Yeah, there is a
Speaker:learned helplessness where--
Speaker:That's not a good one.
Speaker:Uh-huh.
Speaker:That, you know, of course
Speaker:everybody wants to take the path
Speaker:of least resistance and
Speaker:it is easier to stay home
Speaker:than go to school.
Speaker:Everybody wants to do that, right?
Speaker:Yeah, so compassion does not mean
Speaker:forgiving all the learning
Speaker:that had to happen, okay?
Speaker:It just means you're
Speaker:saying to the student,
Speaker:"I have confidence in you.
Speaker:I know you can do this.
Speaker:Let's get you caught up."
Speaker:Yep, absolutely.
Speaker:Absolutely.
Speaker:And it's not easy when you're,
Speaker:it's not even easy for a textbook teacher
Speaker:because there is some instruction
Speaker:that needs to happen to understand.
Speaker:But the textbook does
Speaker:scaffold that instruction
Speaker:so the teacher is not as necessary
Speaker:as it is in comprehensive input.
Speaker:And we've got Elizabeth--
Speaker:When I started, I was out of
Speaker:the textbook the first year.
Speaker:So, because that's where we start, right?
Speaker:We all start there.
Speaker:Yeah, so sorry to interrupt.
Speaker:Liz was there. No, sorry.
Speaker:Is there a way you can
Speaker:look at the questions
Speaker:I sent you through the email
Speaker:before the end of your live chat?
Speaker:Let me go ahead and get them right here.
Speaker:Don't ever be sorry for
Speaker:being part of the conversation.
Speaker:Exactly.
Speaker:Let's see, Elizabeth, okay.
Speaker:What can I talk about
Speaker:while you're looking things up?
Speaker:What did we miss?
Speaker:I think we got
Speaker:everything that I had on my list.
Speaker:Yeah, I think a student
Speaker:with an attendance problem
Speaker:is struggling in many, many ways
Speaker:and it's our job to support them.
Speaker:I talked about in school
Speaker:suspension, how much I hate that.
Speaker:Okay, let me get this on my notes
Speaker:so I can see all the questions.
Speaker:I guess copy and
Speaker:paste them from the email.
Speaker:That's okay, uh-huh.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:One thing that some people
Speaker:suggest for absent students
Speaker:and just for in general,
Speaker:they have choice boards.
Speaker:Yes. Okay?
Speaker:And the students choose the same.
Speaker:I hate choice boards.
Speaker:I have never been able to make them work.
Speaker:I spend hours and
Speaker:hours making a choice board
Speaker:and in the end, the
Speaker:students always choose
Speaker:the same one choice.
Speaker:Maybe one student will
Speaker:choose a second choice
Speaker:and so for me, it's too much work for me
Speaker:to make a choice board.
Speaker:So I don't do that.
Speaker:Maybe somebody, a better
Speaker:teacher than I can make it work.
Speaker:Yeah, I did it.
Speaker:When I used to give homework,
Speaker:I used to have something similar.
Speaker:It wasn't exactly a choice
Speaker:board, but I had different,
Speaker:because what I told them to do,
Speaker:the homework was
Speaker:differentiated for each student.
Speaker:I would tell them, they
Speaker:could see in the grade book
Speaker:which skill they were lacking,
Speaker:and I would have like
Speaker:three or four activities
Speaker:under each thing and
Speaker:my glasses just broke.
Speaker:So they're cheap.
Speaker:They're a lot of blue light glasses.
Speaker:That's all they are.
Speaker:They're not readers
Speaker:or anything like that,
Speaker:but I don't know why I
Speaker:keep buying the same brand
Speaker:because they keep breaking the same way
Speaker:and I'm like, they never leave my desk.
Speaker:So I don't know what it is.
Speaker:So I would have like
Speaker:three or four activities
Speaker:for each of those to go.
Speaker:If you're one of those speaking kids
Speaker:and need help with the speaking,
Speaker:pick one of these activities.
Speaker:And I'd give it to them on Monday
Speaker:and then they had all
Speaker:week plus the weekend
Speaker:because everything was
Speaker:due the following Monday.
Speaker:They could plan
Speaker:whenever they wanted to do it.
Speaker:That's kind of how I did it,
Speaker:but I don't give homework anymore,
Speaker:so I don't worry about that anymore.
Speaker:But what I do have, we have our,
Speaker:you have your contact time
Speaker:that you have with your kids
Speaker:and we have our intervention time.
Speaker:So we call ours PAWS,
Speaker:which goes with our mascot,
Speaker:which is a wildcat.
Speaker:Yeah, we're all giving it cutesy names.
Speaker:That's gonna make it better.
Speaker:I know, I forgot what it stands for,
Speaker:but it does stand for something,
Speaker:but it does spell PAWS.
Speaker:So we call it PAWS time.
Speaker:It's 30 minutes every
Speaker:day, except for Mondays
Speaker:because we have
Speaker:Mondays, a short day for PLCs.
Speaker:And I'll have PAWS activities.
Speaker:So the kids I assign in PAWS,
Speaker:I have an extra class in my
Speaker:formative that's called PAWS.
Speaker:And I just have to
Speaker:insert the kids in there
Speaker:because I've already
Speaker:assigned these extra activities
Speaker:reading, speaking and writing.
Speaker:I do five per chapter for that in there.
Speaker:Oh, this says her
Speaker:school has a wildcat too.
Speaker:Awesome. Yeah.
Speaker:I guess it's one of the,
Speaker:I was told during my
Speaker:interview for this job
Speaker:that it's the number one choice
Speaker:for a mascot in the country.
Speaker:It is.
Speaker:It's some kind of cat or
Speaker:some kind of dog, yeah.
Speaker:So anyway, so I have that built in
Speaker:and when they come in for PAWS,
Speaker:I go, what area do you need help in?
Speaker:I need help in speaking.
Speaker:Do the PAWS speaking activities.
Speaker:So I do that kind of thing.
Speaker:Let me give you these
Speaker:questions that we have got,
Speaker:that we've got from Elizabeth here.
Speaker:And thanks for contributing Elizabeth.
Speaker:Yes, absolutely.
Speaker:Thanks for being our
Speaker:invisible guest host.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:(laughs) Let me put these in here so
Speaker:we can see them on the screen.
Speaker:I can copy and paste
Speaker:them, put them right there.
Speaker:There we go.
Speaker:Here's our first one.
Speaker:It says, which AI program do you use
Speaker:to highlight single words in a text
Speaker:with their isolated translation?
Speaker:Is it, no, it's not an actual program.
Speaker:I asked Claude to make me one.
Speaker:So you can have
Speaker:Claude make things for you,
Speaker:make you actual applications.
Speaker:And so I made one, I
Speaker:told it what I wanted,
Speaker:it to be able to do.
Speaker:And then when the kids do it,
Speaker:it accesses my Claude account
Speaker:to do the translations live.
Speaker:They don't know that,
Speaker:because I have it on a website.
Speaker:They don't know it's accessing,
Speaker:but it's accessing my Claude to do the
Speaker:actual translations.
Speaker:But it only does it once.
Speaker:So once it knows that
Speaker:text, it will save the text.
Speaker:So another kid can just pull up that one,
Speaker:and it's not accessing my
Speaker:Claude for every student,
Speaker:just the first student who uses it.
Speaker:So I made it.
Speaker:So if you have a chat GPT or a Claude
Speaker:or some kind of AI account,
Speaker:you can ask them to
Speaker:make something similar.
Speaker:It wasn't very difficult.
Speaker:And you don't have to be a
Speaker:coder or anything like that.
Speaker:You just tell it what you want.
Speaker:I want my students to be
Speaker:able to paste a story in,
Speaker:in X language.
Speaker:And I want them to be
Speaker:able to click on a word
Speaker:and that word get translated.
Speaker:And then I looked at the
Speaker:translations it was giving me.
Speaker:And I'm like, I need it.
Speaker:I told to modify it.
Speaker:Like I like to use for
Speaker:translation of the verb estar.
Speaker:I want it to be
Speaker:translated as to be located
Speaker:or to be feeling
Speaker:whatever makes the most sense.
Speaker:So I told it that
Speaker:don't translate it as is
Speaker:because my kids aren't
Speaker:gonna learn the difference
Speaker:between how to use the stop.
Speaker:So they it's when it
Speaker:says she is when it says
Speaker:(speaking in foreign language)
Speaker:it translates it as she is feeling happy.
Speaker:So I look at the
Speaker:translations and make sure
Speaker:I also put for verbs.
Speaker:I want it to be not
Speaker:he slash she slash one
Speaker:because that's what it likes to do.
Speaker:So I like to do it in my
Speaker:class just he slash she.
Speaker:I like to do it that way.
Speaker:And I don't like you plural.
Speaker:I put y'all.
Speaker:I used to use you guys,
Speaker:but then a lady told me that
Speaker:that was offensive to women.
Speaker:And I go, I didn't realize that I did
Speaker:never thought of it.
Speaker:So yeah, I say y'all
Speaker:cause I'm from Alabama,
Speaker:but I tell my students is you
Speaker:guys, you folks, you people,
Speaker:you young
Speaker:whipperspippers, you know you want.
Speaker:Exactly. I did the same thing,
Speaker:but I've been trying not to use you guys
Speaker:and anything anymore.
Speaker:So she goes, I'm not a guy.
Speaker:And I'm like, I'm sorry,
Speaker:I didn't mean it that way.
Speaker:I just thought it was colloquial.
Speaker:I've heard girls
Speaker:calling each other, you guys.
Speaker:Yeah, I do too.
Speaker:Depending on where your country you're from.
Speaker:So I look at the
Speaker:translations and tell it what I want
Speaker:because it is a chat and you tell them
Speaker:what you actually want
Speaker:and they will fix it.
Speaker:It's just like if you
Speaker:have a TA in your classroom
Speaker:and they're not doing what
Speaker:exactly the way you tell them,
Speaker:you give them the feedback and then
Speaker:they'll make the changes.
Speaker:So I have my own that I use
Speaker:and you can just have
Speaker:one, if you use one,
Speaker:you can have it make it.
Speaker:And once it's made, it's made.
Speaker:So then that was it.
Speaker:So I had that one made.
Speaker:The next one, I don't even
Speaker:know if we're gonna be able
Speaker:to put this all up on.
Speaker:Okay, let's see how much
Speaker:of this we're gonna be able
Speaker:to get on the screen here.
Speaker:We can do it in sections.
Speaker:Yeah, okay.
Speaker:Do you keep all of the
Speaker:things you do in class
Speaker:for the absentees or
Speaker:the ones who attended,
Speaker:but might have missed
Speaker:out on something anyway?
Speaker:I do and it takes me a long time.
Speaker:Okay, I have an answer for this
Speaker:because Scott gave me
Speaker:this, oh, how many months ago?
Speaker:Scott convinced me to
Speaker:have classroom jobs.
Speaker:And one of my classroom jobs is historian
Speaker:for writing what we did in class.
Speaker:And then now it doesn't take me any time.
Speaker:I just take the historian's notes.
Speaker:And if I want to, I
Speaker:can scan them or I can,
Speaker:I do keep a journal.
Speaker:And I think this is really great.
Speaker:This has helped me on
Speaker:all of my evaluations
Speaker:ever since I started teaching,
Speaker:because at the end of the
Speaker:day, I sit down and I say,
Speaker:I did this, it worked.
Speaker:I did this, it didn't work.
Speaker:I did this next time I'm gonna do this.
Speaker:So me keeping track of
Speaker:what happens in my class
Speaker:helps me be a better teacher.
Speaker:So that journaling is great.
Speaker:And so when I've got the
Speaker:classroom historian now,
Speaker:I just sit down with what they wrote
Speaker:instead of me making the notes of I did
Speaker:this, this, and this,
Speaker:then I can put that into my
Speaker:journal at the end of the day.
Speaker:And then when I have
Speaker:my teacher evaluation
Speaker:and they need some
Speaker:Danielson criterion 4.8 section,
Speaker:I'm like, oh yeah,
Speaker:I've got that right here
Speaker:because I journaled it.
Speaker:So it makes my life easier.
Speaker:And I think it makes me a better teacher
Speaker:because reflection is
Speaker:always the piece that we miss.
Speaker:So I'm not like writing
Speaker:necessarily individual things
Speaker:like this student did
Speaker:this, this student did this.
Speaker:I'm just writing the basic overview of
Speaker:what we did in class,
Speaker:what worked, what I still,
Speaker:what I need to tweak for next time,
Speaker:what I wanna continue
Speaker:tomorrow, that kind of thing.
Speaker:And I do the same thing
Speaker:I do on a weekly basis.
Speaker:I don't have time to do it on a daily,
Speaker:but I do it on a weekly.
Speaker:So that is a good suggestion.
Speaker:I will say there's a
Speaker:couple of things that I do.
Speaker:I have the absentee manager.
Speaker:She calls it the historian
Speaker:I call the absentee manager.
Speaker:Their job is multifaceted.
Speaker:So they go onto the
Speaker:learning management system
Speaker:and we have like on Google classroom,
Speaker:they have like that feed.
Speaker:And we use Schoology,
Speaker:which also has a feed.
Speaker:And so I open up a one on there
Speaker:and then the school
Speaker:absentee manager will go through
Speaker:and will post what we
Speaker:did in class that day.
Speaker:So anybody can check back on there.
Speaker:That's one thing they do.
Speaker:They also will collect.
Speaker:So if I pass out anything, they have,
Speaker:they get the extra one.
Speaker:So if I've got four kids absent,
Speaker:they're gonna get four additional papers
Speaker:and then they're gonna
Speaker:write the kids names on them.
Speaker:And the kid knows and they come back
Speaker:to go see the absentee
Speaker:manager to get those papers.
Speaker:So they're not coming
Speaker:up to me about that.
Speaker:So do that.
Speaker:And then I keep a
Speaker:running list of vocabulary.
Speaker:It is not vocabulary they have to learn.
Speaker:It is vocabulary that we used in class
Speaker:to make it comprehensible.
Speaker:It's kind of like my closed caption.
Speaker:I don't do it by sentence.
Speaker:I do it by word, but I have a Google doc.
Speaker:I used to use
Speaker:Microsoft Word back in the day,
Speaker:but now we have Google
Speaker:docs, which works much better.
Speaker:I make a table.
Speaker:So it's a two column
Speaker:table and I then color code.
Speaker:So one side of the table is one color.
Speaker:The other side of the
Speaker:table is the other color.
Speaker:I preset this up as a template.
Speaker:I have one for every class.
Speaker:Now, cause Google docs added this,
Speaker:the tabbed window in there.
Speaker:So I used to have a
Speaker:different file for every class.
Speaker:So period one, period
Speaker:two, now I don't have to.
Speaker:Each class has a
Speaker:different tab in the one file.
Speaker:And I just type in it and
Speaker:I share this document out.
Speaker:So I share it once, make it public,
Speaker:put the link on my
Speaker:learning management system
Speaker:and a kid can go to any
Speaker:day and see the vocab.
Speaker:Is that their vocab list?
Speaker:Absolutely not.
Speaker:There are words that come
Speaker:up there that don't meet,
Speaker:aren't going to show up ever again.
Speaker:But I wrote it up there because I needed
Speaker:to be comprehensible at that moment.
Speaker:And it's easier than
Speaker:me writing on the board.
Speaker:I have limited board space.
Speaker:And so this is easier and the kids can
Speaker:see it all the time.
Speaker:Another thing that the
Speaker:absentee manager will do
Speaker:will take a picture of the
Speaker:board at the end of class.
Speaker:Oh yeah, okay.
Speaker:I let them do that.
Speaker:So they'll do that and they'll post that
Speaker:in my learning management's in the,
Speaker:in Schoology or whatever you use.
Speaker:They can go ahead and post that
Speaker:information in there.
Speaker:And so that works well for them.
Speaker:Other than that, I
Speaker:don't do anything extra
Speaker:for absentee kids to
Speaker:record what went on with class.
Speaker:When I have 197
Speaker:students, I just can't keep up
Speaker:with all that little
Speaker:minutia all the time.
Speaker:My brain is, you know, I
Speaker:got to grade everything
Speaker:within 24 hours.
Speaker:I got to answer all
Speaker:emails within 24 hours.
Speaker:I've got other things on my plate.
Speaker:And usually if they're absent one or
Speaker:maybe even two days,
Speaker:they're good.
Speaker:It's when they start getting absent more
Speaker:that it becomes more of an issue.
Speaker:And then it hits my
Speaker:radar a little bit more.
Speaker:But I can't keep
Speaker:track of, like on Friday,
Speaker:my seventh period, which
Speaker:is not language, thank gosh,
Speaker:it was multicultural.
Speaker:I had like out of 27 kids, I had like
Speaker:eight people absent.
Speaker:I'm like, why?
Speaker:We don't have a holiday.
Speaker:We don't have any, you
Speaker:know, we didn't have anything.
Speaker:This last week was crazy.
Speaker:So a lot of kids took off
Speaker:because we had Veterans Day.
Speaker:So they took off
Speaker:Wednesday, Thursday, Friday.
Speaker:And I wouldn't know if
Speaker:those kids were also absent
Speaker:on Thursday, because I
Speaker:see them every other day.
Speaker:So I don't know if they
Speaker:took that rest of the week off
Speaker:or not, but I had a lot
Speaker:of kids who were absent
Speaker:on that Friday.
Speaker:And I was like, oh my gosh, but it's,
Speaker:that is a much more
Speaker:manageable because that is con,
Speaker:it's not a comprehensible input.
Speaker:Yeah, yeah.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:Elizabeth says she's
Speaker:got to leave by 11 30.
Speaker:That's not a problem.
Speaker:We'll answer for everybody live here.
Speaker:We'll not as well.
Speaker:So you can just catch the
Speaker:ending and see that on YouTube
Speaker:or on the podcast, because we'll go ahead
Speaker:and finish entering.
Speaker:Because I think everybody
Speaker:will benefit from the answers
Speaker:to these questions,
Speaker:but thank you for asking
Speaker:and enjoy the rest of your weekend.
Speaker:Glad you could make it Elizabeth.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:Okay, let's see.
Speaker:What's your next question?
Speaker:Next one is, oh, this one's for you.
Speaker:Cause I do not do this.
Speaker:You're welcome.
Speaker:Okay, here I put this one up.
Speaker:Can you expand on the interactive note?
Speaker:Oh yeah, okay.
Speaker:Is it on paper?
Speaker:My students will use their school
Speaker:assigned Chromebook,
Speaker:but the majority get
Speaker:distracted when on their laptop.
Speaker:So ask them to go to their.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:So this is where I start
Speaker:from is that there has been
Speaker:so many research papers
Speaker:written on how handwriting
Speaker:aids memory recognition.
Speaker:Yep, absolutely.
Speaker:handwriting is
Speaker:activating the brain in ways
Speaker:that typing on the computer
Speaker:will never activate the brain.
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:Memory is visual and spatial.
Speaker:So I'm sure there's a lot
Speaker:of like just moving your hand
Speaker:around the
Speaker:kinesthetic, your hands on paper.
Speaker:Yeah, you can doodle,
Speaker:you can draw letters
Speaker:in different shapes and stuff.
Speaker:And interactive notebooks,
Speaker:they're kind of expensive for me
Speaker:cause I have to use some
Speaker:of our department funds
Speaker:to buy each student a notebook
Speaker:because I could tell
Speaker:the students they have to,
Speaker:but then not everyone would
Speaker:have them all at the same time
Speaker:because some aren't going to go down to
Speaker:the store immediately
Speaker:and some aren't going
Speaker:to go down to the store.
Speaker:So I just buy notebooks
Speaker:for all of my students.
Speaker:And then I have been
Speaker:collecting ideas from anybody I can
Speaker:for what to put in the
Speaker:interactive notebook.
Speaker:So I'm a game-based classroom
Speaker:because I feel like students
Speaker:are applying their skills better.
Speaker:We talked a little bit about the
Speaker:effective filter earlier on.
Speaker:The student is like too
Speaker:shy to say, "Are" out loud.
Speaker:Cause if they say, "Are" out loud,
Speaker:they're going to say it wrong
Speaker:and they're going to be sound stupid
Speaker:and everyone's going to laugh at them.
Speaker:So, you know what, I just
Speaker:won't say, "Are" at all.
Speaker:And then they don't
Speaker:learn how to say, "Are."
Speaker:Okay.
Speaker:So I turned to games
Speaker:because it really
Speaker:lowers the effective filter.
Speaker:And I get a lot more
Speaker:authentic language production
Speaker:out of the students because
Speaker:they're not like memorizing
Speaker:I grew up on the audio-lingual method
Speaker:and then you memorize the
Speaker:skit and then you say the skit.
Speaker:And then after the skit, you
Speaker:never use those words again.
Speaker:But anyway, so I'm game-based.
Speaker:And I was trying to think,
Speaker:how am I going to make
Speaker:teaching the students
Speaker:how to take notes?
Speaker:Cause they don't know
Speaker:how to take notes anymore.
Speaker:How do I teach them how to
Speaker:take notes in a way that's fun
Speaker:and interactive and game-based?
Speaker:So the interactive notebook
Speaker:has as many little flippy
Speaker:things in it as I can think of.
Speaker:So some of it is like,
Speaker:I'm one of five Spanish teachers.
Speaker:The other four Spanish
Speaker:teachers think that conjugation
Speaker:is the most foundational
Speaker:thing you can do in Spanish.
Speaker:It's important.
Speaker:I don't disagree that it's important.
Speaker:So by golly, I have
Speaker:to teach my first year
Speaker:Spanish students how to conjugate.
Speaker:And flashcards are kind of dull,
Speaker:but if you do it in
Speaker:an interactive notebook
Speaker:where they flip it
Speaker:open to see the answers,
Speaker:it feels more like a game.
Speaker:They can also add color.
Speaker:I've got colored
Speaker:pencils on each of the desks.
Speaker:So they can, like,
Speaker:it's easier for them to,
Speaker:conjugation is a very abstract thing.
Speaker:This makes it a little more concrete.
Speaker:When we're working on a story,
Speaker:I can have the students fold up a little,
Speaker:tiny little flippy book,
Speaker:and then they can illustrate
Speaker:the story in the flippy book
Speaker:and they can paste that into their
Speaker:interactive notebook.
Speaker:So on my each table
Speaker:group, I have six table groups.
Speaker:So about 36 students per class,
Speaker:six set each table group.
Speaker:In the middle of the
Speaker:table, I've got colored pencils
Speaker:and I've got a jar with glue sticks.
Speaker:And I used to leave
Speaker:scissors in the jar too,
Speaker:but I can't do that anymore
Speaker:because the students
Speaker:were taking the scissors
Speaker:and cutting all sorts of crazy stuff.
Speaker:So, and then I used to
Speaker:have a ruler in there,
Speaker:but then they were breaking my ruler.
Speaker:So I bring out the scissors
Speaker:in the rulers when I need to.
Speaker:That's another classroom
Speaker:job, handing those out.
Speaker:And then the glue sticks are always there
Speaker:and the colored pencils are always there.
Speaker:And just as many different ways
Speaker:I can get the students to
Speaker:interact with the vocabulary.
Speaker:So we were talking
Speaker:about prepositions earlier.
Speaker:The students have a page of their book
Speaker:where they basically
Speaker:doodle the prepositions
Speaker:and there's no English
Speaker:in the book whatsoever,
Speaker:but they can write the
Speaker:preposition and they can doodle it
Speaker:so that they're not
Speaker:confused like with Rosetta Stone
Speaker:because the students came up.
Speaker:The students themselves came up with,
Speaker:ah, next to is going to
Speaker:be the puppy and the ball
Speaker:next to the puppy, you know,
Speaker:or whatever it is that they came up with.
Speaker:So I've been making YouTube videos about
Speaker:everything I'm doing
Speaker:in the interactive notebook.
Speaker:So I'll send you to my YouTube channel
Speaker:if you want the down
Speaker:and dirty on all of that.
Speaker:But I'm really glad I'm doing it.
Speaker:And the students have that crutch.
Speaker:And then when we play a game, you know,
Speaker:all I really care is are
Speaker:you producing language?
Speaker:So generally I will say you have your
Speaker:interactive notebooks
Speaker:out next to you so that
Speaker:you don't fail this game.
Speaker:Cause if I hear any
Speaker:English, that's when you fail.
Speaker:It's not if you say things badly,
Speaker:it's if you drop into English.
Speaker:Cause you know, I mean,
Speaker:saying something badly
Speaker:is still communicating, right?
Speaker:So.
Speaker:Yes, and there's easy to
Speaker:get Pamela's YouTube channel.
Speaker:I made a link for it to
Speaker:make it easy for everybody.
Speaker:So you can go to mm.us slash Pamela
Speaker:and that'll bring you right to her
Speaker:amazing YouTube channel.
Speaker:So it's there.
Speaker:It's also, it's in the
Speaker:link in the description
Speaker:and show notes as well.
Speaker:So you can see it there.
Speaker:It's up there every week, but
Speaker:I just put it up on the screen
Speaker:for those who can see that.
Speaker:So thank you very much.
Speaker:And I don't do interactive notebooks.
Speaker:I had a teacher who did notebooks,
Speaker:not necessarily interactive ones
Speaker:and put a lot of time
Speaker:grading the notebooks.
Speaker:I'm like, Oh gosh.
Speaker:I don't grade them.
Speaker:This is for the students.
Speaker:I don't grade them. Exactly.
Speaker:Notebooks are for the students.
Speaker:They are not to be graded.
Speaker:That doesn't tell you how
Speaker:much language they can do.
Speaker:But I am also, I, my kids hate this
Speaker:because I tell them,
Speaker:we need to copy the vocabulary down.
Speaker:And I break it up because literally
Speaker:I think my textbook has like 200 words.
Speaker:Oh, your textbook has
Speaker:like 150 words per chapter.
Speaker:Yeah. And so I break it up and I do it
Speaker:because it takes me six
Speaker:weeks to get through a chapter.
Speaker:So the first two weeks
Speaker:on that Monday or Tuesday
Speaker:because it's odd or even days,
Speaker:I will post half the vocab
Speaker:and they have to copy it down.
Speaker:And then the other then on the second,
Speaker:not the second week,
Speaker:because then the third week,
Speaker:Monday or Tuesday, the
Speaker:kids will get the second half
Speaker:because I can't give them,
Speaker:have them copy 150 words done at once.
Speaker:It's just ludicrous.
Speaker:But I have it.
Speaker:And then I give them the vocab list.
Speaker:I make an infographic of it.
Speaker:And I give that to them after.
Speaker:They're like, why can't we just use this?
Speaker:I go, because there is something about
Speaker:actually writing it.
Speaker:You need to have it.
Speaker:Your memory will start getting
Speaker:when you start doing the actual letters.
Speaker:And I know when I'm learning Maltese.
Speaker:No.
Speaker:Yeah. When I'm learning
Speaker:Maltese, it's the same thing.
Speaker:I'm not, I have not because
Speaker:we're doing it on the computer.
Speaker:We're doing it through Zoom.
Speaker:So I have not written down
Speaker:and I know I need to start doing that.
Speaker:I just don't have the time right now
Speaker:to actually start
Speaker:writing some of this down.
Speaker:I want to start doing my
Speaker:own quick writes with Maltese
Speaker:and seeing what I can actually express.
Speaker:Cause I've got to do that
Speaker:because my guy is not a CI teacher,
Speaker:but I need this to be
Speaker:able to be helpful for me.
Speaker:So there is something
Speaker:about writing it down.
Speaker:And I know this because I
Speaker:have never been a note taker.
Speaker:I didn't know how to take
Speaker:notes through high school.
Speaker:In college, I had to learn
Speaker:how to take notes real quick
Speaker:because you can't survive.
Speaker:And I was, I go, I
Speaker:need to do this easier.
Speaker:I'm a slow handwriter.
Speaker:I can't do all of that.
Speaker:And I didn't really
Speaker:understand about knowing.
Speaker:I couldn't figure out,
Speaker:I didn't understand all those lessons
Speaker:that they told us in English.
Speaker:Find the main sentence of this paragraph.
Speaker:What are the supporting?
Speaker:If they would have said,
Speaker:this is how we take notes.
Speaker:I go, I could put the
Speaker:two things together,
Speaker:but they never said
Speaker:that's what we were learning
Speaker:how to do, right?
Speaker:So I had to learn all
Speaker:of that and I would type.
Speaker:Cause I can type pretty
Speaker:fast, but then I don't retain it.
Speaker:And so now I'm very digital.
Speaker:I'm very tech.
Speaker:I love my tech.
Speaker:I'm not giving up my tech
Speaker:and I don't want to use paper notebooks.
Speaker:So I bought a paper tablet.
Speaker:So it works like a Kindle.
Speaker:I don't use the Kindle one.
Speaker:The Kindle one's not as good as other
Speaker:ones for note-taking.
Speaker:And so I do it and then I actually write.
Speaker:I used to use an iPad and I call,
Speaker:I like to color code my stuff.
Speaker:So I used to use an iPad and do that.
Speaker:And I would color code.
Speaker:And I know I retain so much more,
Speaker:but now I use an actual
Speaker:dedicated tablet that is in color.
Speaker:I've got black and white
Speaker:version and a color version
Speaker:that uses the E Ink technology.
Speaker:So it's not hard on your eyes.
Speaker:And I can still do my color
Speaker:coding and stuff like that.
Speaker:And I find that works better for me.
Speaker:Plus I like mine to be neat and organized
Speaker:and pretty and good looking and stuff.
Speaker:And so I can't do that live.
Speaker:Like some people can
Speaker:doodle and stuff live
Speaker:and keep their ears open.
Speaker:I will lose track of
Speaker:what I'm doing about,
Speaker:oh, that was an important sentence.
Speaker:I was in the middle of drawing the doodle
Speaker:for the last thing and I can't do it.
Speaker:So I know it's always good to practice
Speaker:recopying your notes.
Speaker:Right, oh man, that is
Speaker:like, that's studying, right?
Speaker:Yeah, so I take my
Speaker:ugly notes that I wrote
Speaker:and then I can go ahead and rewrite them
Speaker:and make them pretty and
Speaker:do all the color coding
Speaker:I wanna do and stuff like that,
Speaker:make it all organized, rearrange.
Speaker:That's also nice with digital
Speaker:because I can circle
Speaker:one paragraph and go,
Speaker:oh, that would be
Speaker:better if I put it up here
Speaker:with that point. Over here, yeah.
Speaker:Yeah, and I can drag and drop.
Speaker:Yeah, it probably helps your sketch
Speaker:noting so much better.
Speaker:Sketch noting is a
Speaker:technique I teach my students.
Speaker:Yep, I like sketch noting. Sketch noting,
Speaker:sketch doodle, yep.
Speaker:So I do that and then it
Speaker:works really, really well
Speaker:and plus it's digital so
Speaker:I can access it anywhere.
Speaker:I can print it out and if
Speaker:you really want it typed out
Speaker:after you hand-wrote it,
Speaker:you can convert it over to typed text.
Speaker:Yep, probably. So it works all,
Speaker:it works really, really nice,
Speaker:but it will search in your
Speaker:handwriting as well and find it.
Speaker:You don't have to have it texted
Speaker:to find something in your handwriting.
Speaker:Oh, that's cool. And it can read
Speaker:pretty bad handwriting.
Speaker:So I like that and it really works for me
Speaker:and I learned about that rewriting
Speaker:because I never used to do that,
Speaker:but my geography teacher in college said,
Speaker:"I don't care about the textbook.
Speaker:"Our tests are on the textbook.
Speaker:"The final is on my lectures
Speaker:"and I will talk for three hours
Speaker:"and you need to take notes."
Speaker:And on the,
Speaker:for the final exam, I'm
Speaker:telling you right now what it is.
Speaker:You need to regurgitate my notes
Speaker:from day one through the last week.
Speaker:So we had three hour class,
Speaker:once a week for 15 weeks.
Speaker:So we had 15 three hour works of notes.
Speaker:And he goes, "The only way
Speaker:you're gonna be able to do this
Speaker:"is on day one, you go home,
Speaker:"you recopy day one's notes.
Speaker:"On day two, you recopy day one notes
Speaker:"and then you add on day two notes.
Speaker:"On day three, you recopy
Speaker:day one, day two, day three."
Speaker:So at work, I was not
Speaker:a teacher at the time.
Speaker:I was working at the airline
Speaker:and I was on the phone talking to people.
Speaker:So while I was recopying the notes
Speaker:over and over and over again.
Speaker:And so on day 15, before the final,
Speaker:I was recopying day
Speaker:one, day two, day three,
Speaker:day four, day five, you
Speaker:know, the whole thing.
Speaker:And I retained it and on the final exam
Speaker:for three hours for the final,
Speaker:I redid it from memory
Speaker:because I had to do it
Speaker:from memory at that point.
Speaker:And I could do it.
Speaker:I had a graduate
Speaker:school class like that too.
Speaker:So it really did help.
Speaker:So writing is really, really important.
Speaker:Okay, let's go to the next question here.
Speaker:"What is the success of your students?")
Speaker:And I noticed when I put them in here,
Speaker:they're getting cut off.
Speaker:So I'll read the whole thing
Speaker:from actually what she put in here.
Speaker:Cause it's only gonna post so much.
Speaker:Okay, the other one says,
Speaker:teaching resilience,
Speaker:making little successes
Speaker:attainable for those students
Speaker:and recognizing, praising
Speaker:these successes for students
Speaker:who will remember being recognized
Speaker:for having made the effort.
Speaker:I have many students with 504s
Speaker:more than I have ever had
Speaker:who are not necessarily
Speaker:encouraged to follow through
Speaker:and keep trying.
Speaker:Do you have strategies to
Speaker:encourage these students?
Speaker:I will tell you the
Speaker:main big one is my cards.
Speaker:And I learned that from my
Speaker:old school, my middle school.
Speaker:We all got a running list.
Speaker:It was a spreadsheet
Speaker:of every kid on campus.
Speaker:And our goal was to make sure
Speaker:that every teacher
Speaker:reached out to every kid
Speaker:they had with a postcard
Speaker:and they were generic postcards.
Speaker:They didn't say anything on there.
Speaker:It just had the school logo on it.
Speaker:And then you wrote something on the back
Speaker:twice for the whole year.
Speaker:And you could check on the,
Speaker:every time you wrote one to a kid,
Speaker:you're supposed to log it.
Speaker:You don't have to write
Speaker:what you wrote, but just said,
Speaker:so on such and such
Speaker:date, this kid got one.
Speaker:And so then you can go
Speaker:through and you go, okay,
Speaker:I have Johnny so and so
Speaker:let me look on the list.
Speaker:He hasn't gotten any yet.
Speaker:So that's gonna be my
Speaker:next kid that I wanna do.
Speaker:Sarah has gotten four already.
Speaker:She's gotten enough encouragement.
Speaker:Yes, I still need to give my two to her,
Speaker:but she can wait.
Speaker:Johnny can't, cause he's not gotten any
Speaker:from any teacher yet.
Speaker:So that was really kind of helpful.
Speaker:And I kind of have that
Speaker:mentality in my classroom.
Speaker:I look for ways to encourage my kids.
Speaker:Um, whenever I possibly can.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:At least twice per year.
Speaker:And it might be a negative thing.
Speaker:Like I said, I have gotten a much,
Speaker:instead of tattling on a kid,
Speaker:and I can't do this on my own.
Speaker:I'm gonna be honest.
Speaker:I cannot, I am not, I'm a realist.
Speaker:I'm not an optimist.
Speaker:I'm not a pessimist.
Speaker:I am a realist.
Speaker:I tell it like it is.
Speaker:I have some autistic
Speaker:characteristics myself.
Speaker:So I don't sugar coat.
Speaker:I just tell it and it comes out mean.
Speaker:It does.
Speaker:I recognize this in myself.
Speaker:So I will put it, I go, okay,
Speaker:Johnny is sleeping in class
Speaker:and he's listening to his earbuds
Speaker:during the whole
Speaker:class while he's sleeping.
Speaker:I need a polite,
Speaker:friendly and professional email
Speaker:to mom and dad with some compassion
Speaker:to send to mom and dad.
Speaker:And then it gives me a thanks.
Speaker:Mr. and Mrs. So and So.
Speaker:I have noticed that poor Johnny
Speaker:has not been getting enough sleep at home
Speaker:and has been sleeping.
Speaker:Is there something
Speaker:going on in class at home
Speaker:that I should know about?
Speaker:Or perhaps you can talk with him
Speaker:and we can partner as a
Speaker:team to help Johnny be more.
Speaker:So it's much nicer about that.
Speaker:Can you talk about
Speaker:him, about the importance
Speaker:of when it's
Speaker:appropriate to use his earbuds
Speaker:and when it's not?
Speaker:It's all nice, right?
Speaker:Where I could really work at it,
Speaker:but it would take me
Speaker:like 30 minutes to come out.
Speaker:I write my bad email and rewrite it.
Speaker:Try to get it all nice, but then it
Speaker:sounds too worked over.
Speaker:It just, it does not
Speaker:come out well for me.
Speaker:So this works really nice.
Speaker:So I have found before I
Speaker:start the discipline process,
Speaker:I take the bad habit and
Speaker:twist it around positively first.
Speaker:Like, oh, I noticed,
Speaker:I'll write to the kid.
Speaker:I'll write a little, the postcard.
Speaker:Oh, Johnny, I noticed you've
Speaker:been having your earbuds in.
Speaker:You do know our rule
Speaker:that we're not allowed
Speaker:to have our earbuds in during class.
Speaker:Is there something that I can,
Speaker:is there a specific
Speaker:reason why you're doing this?
Speaker:Kind of make it positive.
Speaker:I don't know why I write the postcard.
Speaker:Cause it seems much more friendly
Speaker:than me pulling them out
Speaker:in the hall and saying,
Speaker:putting those earbuds in your ear.
Speaker:I call them Q-tips.
Speaker:I go, get the Q-tip out of your ear.
Speaker:In the thick of the
Speaker:moment, it's hard to pull back.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:But when you, I mean, in the end,
Speaker:we want the students to know
Speaker:that we are their advocate,
Speaker:not their adversary.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:We want them to succeed and
Speaker:we are there to support them.
Speaker:And sometimes it's hard.
Speaker:You have to take a deep breath
Speaker:or you gotta write the
Speaker:email, you know, or whatever,
Speaker:or the card.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:The time to see the
Speaker:good thing about them.
Speaker:And I think the beauty of CI,
Speaker:and certainly my first year teaching
Speaker:when I was teaching out of the
Speaker:textbook, I couldn't do this.
Speaker:But one of the beauties of CI is,
Speaker:you can take whatever
Speaker:problem that you have
Speaker:and you can spin it into,
Speaker:you can make that student
Speaker:the star student of the day.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:You know, oh, this student,
Speaker:all the other teachers
Speaker:are actually using the word
Speaker:psychopath about him.
Speaker:But I happened to
Speaker:mention fishing in our story
Speaker:because I know he likes fishing.
Speaker:Now he has hallway
Speaker:conversation with me about fishing.
Speaker:I have no idea anything about fishing,
Speaker:but suddenly he's my buddy
Speaker:because he knows we're
Speaker:gonna talk about fishing
Speaker:during class in the target language.
Speaker:Exactly.
Speaker:You know?
Speaker:And it's funny, you guys can't--
Speaker:Yeah, go ahead.
Speaker:I'm gonna say our school calls the
Speaker:troublemakers friends.
Speaker:I've got the special friend.
Speaker:I was shocked as I got one student
Speaker:that the two other teachers said,
Speaker:oh, he's a psychopath,
Speaker:like actual psychopath.
Speaker:And I'm like, okay, well, I'm
Speaker:the woman with the gimpy leg.
Speaker:If he gets violent with me,
Speaker:it's gonna be a little
Speaker:difficult, but you know,
Speaker:so you just try to,
Speaker:you can reach them on some level.
Speaker:It's gonna take a little bit of digging,
Speaker:but those hallway
Speaker:conversations are crucial, I think.
Speaker:And when I hear that,
Speaker:that's a good point.
Speaker:When I hear a lot of
Speaker:teachers talking negative
Speaker:about a student, that my goal--
Speaker:It's gonna pull you into their instruction.
Speaker:Yeah, my goal is then to
Speaker:make that student my friend,
Speaker:my classroom friend, not a bad friend
Speaker:like I was just talking about.
Speaker:Not friends, we can't
Speaker:be friends with students.
Speaker:We should not be friends with students
Speaker:because we have to lay down the law.
Speaker:Yeah, but that
Speaker:classroom friend where I'm,
Speaker:yeah, exactly, so
Speaker:that I'm trying to build
Speaker:that relationship with that kid
Speaker:and it's nothing to do
Speaker:with what I'm teaching.
Speaker:I'm just trying to build so
Speaker:he's got a place he can come
Speaker:when he needs it.
Speaker:That's what I find is
Speaker:really helpful when I saw that.
Speaker:But I find those cards, I
Speaker:send emails to all my students,
Speaker:not individually, as a class.
Speaker:So all my Spanish one
Speaker:students get an email,
Speaker:Spanish two students get an email.
Speaker:In there, I will praise certain kids
Speaker:and then I'll call them out,
Speaker:I'll give them shout outs in the email.
Speaker:I'll make it funny so
Speaker:my kids wanna read it.
Speaker:So I do that.
Speaker:I also will send parents the same thing.
Speaker:It's a different email and I
Speaker:might give a shout out there
Speaker:and it's like so and so
Speaker:did really, really great
Speaker:in the class and so it's
Speaker:always positive and I do that.
Speaker:And sometimes I'll write just
Speaker:personal emails to a student
Speaker:about just directly to them.
Speaker:I can't fit what I
Speaker:wanna write on a postcard.
Speaker:I'll probably, it'll be a postcard
Speaker:but then there'll be
Speaker:another email on top of it
Speaker:to encourage them.
Speaker:Because some kids don't
Speaker:like the spotlight either
Speaker:so you don't praise them in class.
Speaker:That doesn't, they don't like that.
Speaker:So you gotta find out who your kid is
Speaker:but building those
Speaker:relationships with the kids
Speaker:in the beginning will really help
Speaker:with this part along the way.
Speaker:Because you can find out
Speaker:which kids like the praise public
Speaker:and which ones don't.
Speaker:Okay, she's got more on anxiety.
Speaker:Students will not
Speaker:record themselves talking
Speaker:and refuse to watch, listen
Speaker:to themselves to self evaluate.
Speaker:I have to speak with
Speaker:them one-on-one for me
Speaker:to get anything out of them
Speaker:for any presentation speaking
Speaker:or interpersonal
Speaker:communicative practice or assessment.
Speaker:Do you have any
Speaker:strategies to be scaffolded
Speaker:as chat mats and sentence starters
Speaker:to get them speaking out loud
Speaker:without having to be there
Speaker:holding their hand in person?
Speaker:Yeah, so one thing I have,
Speaker:this is like my game-based learning.
Speaker:My colleague loves
Speaker:the audio-lingual method
Speaker:and so he makes the students come up
Speaker:to the front of the classroom and present
Speaker:or they have to come in
Speaker:before school, after school
Speaker:or during intervention time
Speaker:to present to him personally.
Speaker:For me, I'm playing a game.
Speaker:I'm walking around with a clipboard
Speaker:and I'm listening to everybody.
Speaker:They'll talk to their buddies just fine.
Speaker:I'm just eavesdropping.
Speaker:So that's how I handle that.
Speaker:Yeah, what I go ahead and
Speaker:do is a couple of things.
Speaker:First of all, they're usually recording
Speaker:because I have them record on formative
Speaker:when it's interactive.
Speaker:So I will record my questions.
Speaker:They'll listen to the question
Speaker:and they'll speak in, I have them video,
Speaker:record themselves right away.
Speaker:So some kids are great with that
Speaker:because nobody else is listening to them
Speaker:because everybody else
Speaker:is doing the same thing.
Speaker:So that helps a little bit.
Speaker:Otherwise, if they are self-conscious,
Speaker:some of them do it in other classes
Speaker:and I don't know why that is.
Speaker:That's weird to me
Speaker:because they'll have an audience
Speaker:in the background who are looking at them
Speaker:as they're doing it.
Speaker:I'm like, "Oh my gosh,
Speaker:that would make me more..."
Speaker:No one else is doing it.
Speaker:You're in biology
Speaker:class and so it stands out.
Speaker:And then other kids
Speaker:just wait till they go home
Speaker:and they do it at home.
Speaker:So that works.
Speaker:I tell them it has to be a video.
Speaker:They start, they always
Speaker:start by blocking off,
Speaker:turning off their
Speaker:camera and making a video
Speaker:and I'm like, "I gotta see your face
Speaker:because I gotta see, is it your voice?"
Speaker:I had a kid, I couldn't
Speaker:tell whose voice it was.
Speaker:So I needed to tell, I
Speaker:need to see your face
Speaker:doing the speaking.
Speaker:I can tell if you're
Speaker:reading from something
Speaker:or if you're actually
Speaker:speaking spontaneously.
Speaker:So I need to see your face.
Speaker:I'm not gonna publish it to this YouTube
Speaker:so everybody can see,
Speaker:but I need to do that.
Speaker:The other thing is presentational.
Speaker:That one is different
Speaker:because that one's live for me.
Speaker:I will have kids get in groups
Speaker:and then they will draw a picture.
Speaker:So if there are five kids in the group,
Speaker:it's a five frame comic.
Speaker:If it's four kids in a
Speaker:group, it's four frames.
Speaker:Each kid's response for
Speaker:only talking about one frame
Speaker:of the story and they
Speaker:stand up in front of the class
Speaker:and they have the picture,
Speaker:all they have is the picture
Speaker:in front of them, no notes.
Speaker:They talk about their
Speaker:picture, they pass the picture along
Speaker:and then the last
Speaker:person gives me the picture
Speaker:so I can verify there are no
Speaker:notes on it and such like that.
Speaker:The picture's not for the audience.
Speaker:I usually tell them if they don't wanna,
Speaker:if they can't do public speaking,
Speaker:they can always put
Speaker:their best face forward
Speaker:and face the wall.
Speaker:True. So that means,
Speaker:that means their back of their head
Speaker:is their best face forward.
Speaker:So they always, I always say it that way.
Speaker:They all chucked a
Speaker:little bit, but I'm like,
Speaker:"You're welcome to face the wall,
Speaker:but everybody's gonna
Speaker:stand up there and do it."
Speaker:You know, it's not public speaking,
Speaker:so I'm not like, "You've got
Speaker:it there, you gotta project,
Speaker:you gotta make eye contact,
Speaker:that's not what it's about,
Speaker:but I need everybody to do it."
Speaker:And they go, "Well, can I
Speaker:do it privately on your own?"
Speaker:I go, "Here's your option.
Speaker:If you do it
Speaker:privately, you're on your own
Speaker:and you've gotta write
Speaker:at least four squares
Speaker:and you gotta do all four squares."
Speaker:If you wanna do it
Speaker:privately, that's the thing.
Speaker:So if that's what you really wanna do,
Speaker:four squares, you
Speaker:gotta talk about them all.
Speaker:Or you can just turn around
Speaker:and talk about one square.
Speaker:And most of the kids
Speaker:just choose to turn around
Speaker:and talk about one square. Yeah.
Speaker:Because I can't just get one square,
Speaker:I'm like, "Where's
Speaker:the rest of the story?"
Speaker:I don't know what, you
Speaker:know, if you're continuing,
Speaker:if it's going, you know, I
Speaker:don't know anything like that.
Speaker:So I'll do that one.
Speaker:She's got a couple
Speaker:more we're gonna finish
Speaker:because we are going really long today.
Speaker:We're really long. But
Speaker:I think it's important.
Speaker:That's good.
Speaker:I'm glad we had that.
Speaker:I think it's important.
Speaker:Audience participation, yeah.
Speaker:Yes.
Speaker:Okay, so this one is,
Speaker:"Slowing down the whole class
Speaker:for the benefit of few stragglers.
Speaker:How can we have other
Speaker:students demonstrate
Speaker:teaching others brings the highest return
Speaker:in the pyramid of learning
Speaker:quickly as a dialogue or
Speaker:retell the story in the moment?"
Speaker:I'm actually against this one.
Speaker:I don't know about your feeling, but
Speaker:bad input is bad input.
Speaker:Yeah, me too. So if a kid,
Speaker:I'm gonna use Gustard as an example.
Speaker:If the kid thinks you
Speaker:conjugate Gustard as Gusto Gustas,
Speaker:Gusta Gustamos Gustan,
Speaker:which you absolutely do not,
Speaker:it does not work that way in Spanish.
Speaker:He's teaching it or
Speaker:retelling a story using that.
Speaker:That is bad input.
Speaker:And so the kid
Speaker:doesn't know that it's wrong
Speaker:and the kid he's listening to,
Speaker:he doesn't know that it's wrong either.
Speaker:And so there's the problem.
Speaker:And here's the prime example
Speaker:in real life why this works.
Speaker:I mean, why it doesn't work.
Speaker:If I go to a native speaker
Speaker:and I speak to him in
Speaker:Spanish, and I'll go,
Speaker:"How did you do on
Speaker:your biology test today?"
Speaker:He will say, "I did well in Spanish."
Speaker:He will never make the mistake between
Speaker:well and good, never.
Speaker:Not in Spanish.
Speaker:I've never, it may happen.
Speaker:I've never heard a native
Speaker:speaker ever make that mistake.
Speaker:But I'll ask them in English,
Speaker:how did you do?
Speaker:He'll go, "I did good on my test."
Speaker:And then I go, "How do
Speaker:you say good in Spanish?"
Speaker:He goes, "Bueno."
Speaker:"How do you say well in Spanish?"
Speaker:"Bien."
Speaker:"How would you say in Spanish?"
Speaker:"Ithe bien."
Speaker:I go, "Then why did you switch to good
Speaker:when you know bien means well?"
Speaker:And the reason is he
Speaker:heard all of the bad input
Speaker:from the English kids, the American kids,
Speaker:who don't know the
Speaker:difference between well and good.
Speaker:Because you can't do good on a test.
Speaker:You can do good versus
Speaker:you can do bad, like evil.
Speaker:Good versus evil.
Speaker:But when you're, you
Speaker:need an adverb there.
Speaker:"I did well on my test."
Speaker:And so bad input begets bad acquisition.
Speaker:So I don't want that in there.
Speaker:And it happens also with twins.
Speaker:When twins come up
Speaker:with their own language,
Speaker:when they're babies with each other,
Speaker:that nobody else understands.
Speaker:And so I don't let them do
Speaker:that in that particular case
Speaker:because of that I want
Speaker:them to get the best input.
Speaker:And I'm not saying my Spanish is perfect.
Speaker:It is far from it, but
Speaker:it's better than the students.
Speaker:And so that's kind of how I look at that.
Speaker:Yeah, uh-huh.
Speaker:And when I do do retails,
Speaker:I have them retail at the
Speaker:same time at each other.
Speaker:So they're not really
Speaker:listening to each other.
Speaker:They're just talking
Speaker:and telling the retail.
Speaker:Because otherwise, if
Speaker:it's a slow processor
Speaker:and a fast processor, the
Speaker:slow processor, you go first,
Speaker:the fast processor goes,
Speaker:and the slow processor just
Speaker:reiterates what they said.
Speaker:They didn't think for themselves.
Speaker:So this way, nobody's
Speaker:listening, nobody's doing it.
Speaker:You're talking at the same time.
Speaker:So I like doing it that way.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:For me, yeah, no, I agree
Speaker:with what you're saying.
Speaker:And I also think that we
Speaker:rely too much on reteaching
Speaker:and so it is true that, who was it?
Speaker:Richard Feynman was
Speaker:like, you don't know anything
Speaker:until you can explain
Speaker:it to an eight-year-old.
Speaker:So there should be
Speaker:some reteaching going on,
Speaker:but for the most
Speaker:part, for the stragglers,
Speaker:I'm just telling the story.
Speaker:And if they miss
Speaker:something, they miss something.
Speaker:Hopefully the story is
Speaker:comprehensible enough
Speaker:that they get the basic gist of it.
Speaker:And if they really don't understand it,
Speaker:they'll have to come in
Speaker:to see me individually
Speaker:because taking too much
Speaker:class time for one student
Speaker:makes everybody bored,
Speaker:and then my class is not
Speaker:a place they wanna come.
Speaker:Yeah, exactly.
Speaker:And I'll say, where are they reteaching?
Speaker:Where that education, the
Speaker:top of Bloom's Taxonomy there,
Speaker:I would have like maybe
Speaker:teaching the vocabulary
Speaker:to have them do that, show the gestures,
Speaker:do that kind of stuff.
Speaker:They could do that.
Speaker:Or explaining a grammar points,
Speaker:they better understand that.
Speaker:But I don't think--
Speaker:They can absolutely do that.
Speaker:I don't think that
Speaker:part of Bloom's Taxonomy
Speaker:translates to being
Speaker:able to retell something
Speaker:that that's teaching
Speaker:something to another kid.
Speaker:I don't think that's not
Speaker:exactly what's happening.
Speaker:They're not processing the
Speaker:language in the same way.
Speaker:Because when someone speaks,
Speaker:the other person's trying to understand
Speaker:and the other person's
Speaker:trying to communicate.
Speaker:So it's not teaching that
Speaker:happens when we talk in Spanish.
Speaker:That's just the byproduct
Speaker:that comes out of acquisition
Speaker:by hearing it.
Speaker:But teaching the grammar
Speaker:or teaching the vocabulary,
Speaker:that is where I think that
Speaker:Bloom's part of the taxonomy.
Speaker:I don't think it works
Speaker:for, and I could be wrong,
Speaker:I'll let no crash in, and the experts,
Speaker:Bill Van Patten, explain it.
Speaker:But I don't think
Speaker:that's what was intended
Speaker:in Bloom's Taxonomy when they put the,
Speaker:to teach somebody else
Speaker:something is the top.
Speaker:I agree.
Speaker:It is when you explain
Speaker:something to somebody else,
Speaker:but you're not explaining the language.
Speaker:You're just using the language.
Speaker:And I think the purpose
Speaker:of that is communication.
Speaker:Yeah, yeah, I agree.
Speaker:Okay, so students who
Speaker:are absent for the story,
Speaker:I take photos of the
Speaker:whiteboard with extra vocabulary,
Speaker:but the appstees will not look
Speaker:at what I posted on my agenda
Speaker:and spend the extra time to catch up.
Speaker:I need to set up a system
Speaker:for them to be accountable
Speaker:for looking up the notes
Speaker:and seeing the new
Speaker:vocabulary and context.
Speaker:I audio record stories
Speaker:for students to listen to.
Speaker:Should ask students who are
Speaker:willing and able to record it,
Speaker:save me the time?
Speaker:I would not do that either.
Speaker:You know what?
Speaker:The story is, it's a simple story, right?
Speaker:You shouldn't have to
Speaker:spin it a 20 millionth time
Speaker:for one student who wasn't there.
Speaker:You should be able to get by with,
Speaker:here are the four
Speaker:sentences that we worked on.
Speaker:Here are the eight
Speaker:sentences of the total story.
Speaker:I don't think I've ever
Speaker:had a story go beyond 10
Speaker:or 11 sentences, really.
Speaker:So just stick with the basics.
Speaker:If they missed it, you can give them the,
Speaker:however many, four to 10 sentences
Speaker:that they need to know
Speaker:to understand the story.
Speaker:The other stuff is, it's
Speaker:icing on the cake, okay?
Speaker:If they remembered that it wasn't a cat
Speaker:who was riding the
Speaker:lawnmower, but it was a dog,
Speaker:when you're circling,
Speaker:there's a bunch of stuff
Speaker:that is just extra, right?
Speaker:So you can ignore all that
Speaker:when you're bringing
Speaker:a student up to speed.
Speaker:And what I usually do,
Speaker:because I work off a five frame story.
Speaker:That's how I always set my stories up.
Speaker:There's a lot more text that goes on it,
Speaker:but my simple story
Speaker:is, there is a character,
Speaker:there is a problem, that's my second
Speaker:sentence of my story,
Speaker:then describe the problem,
Speaker:try to solve it and fail and solve it.
Speaker:Try to solve it and solve it.
Speaker:So you don't even do the
Speaker:try fail cycle three times?
Speaker:No.
Speaker:Here's my three.
Speaker:So I go in threes, but
Speaker:when the students are absent,
Speaker:they don't need to know really each time
Speaker:it tried and failed.
Speaker:They need to know it tried and failed,
Speaker:and they need to know
Speaker:what the success was.
Speaker:And sometimes the
Speaker:success is really goofy,
Speaker:and I don't really care if they know
Speaker:all those esoteric words that the
Speaker:students shouted out to me
Speaker:for so that everything, oh God,
Speaker:we were, one of my
Speaker:students was arm wrestling
Speaker:on the top spire of the Eiffel Tower
Speaker:over a Pokemon card that some famous
Speaker:football player had,
Speaker:and the Pokemon card fell,
Speaker:and the student lost the arm wrestling
Speaker:competition and fell,
Speaker:but he managed to stick the landing
Speaker:right next to the Pokemon
Speaker:card, and he walked off with it.
Speaker:I don't care if you know
Speaker:how to say card in French,
Speaker:it's easy, I don't know,
Speaker:I don't care if you know
Speaker:that there's a
Speaker:difference between la parvie
Speaker:et la sommé in la tour Eiffel,
Speaker:what I care is that
Speaker:you knew the word fall,
Speaker:you knew the word fight,
Speaker:you know, whatever we were
Speaker:working on, the basic stuff,
Speaker:so for the two students who were absent,
Speaker:it wasn't a big deal to bring them up,
Speaker:because in the end the story was,
Speaker:there is this person,
Speaker:he meets this person,
Speaker:this person has something,
Speaker:this person wants something,
Speaker:this person gets
Speaker:something, that was five sentences,
Speaker:that was all I cared about.
Speaker:Yeah, so I was saying,
Speaker:going back to my five sentence story,
Speaker:because I do keep it, I mean, it's more,
Speaker:I use it as a character
Speaker:problem, fail success,
Speaker:that's kind of my little system,
Speaker:and that fifth sentence is always,
Speaker:there is a problem to
Speaker:introduce the problem.
Speaker:Right, right.
Speaker:That's where the fifth sentence comes in,
Speaker:I build my slide deck off of that,
Speaker:because I'm doing TPRS 2.0,
Speaker:so I have, and I talk
Speaker:about one slide per day,
Speaker:so one main sentence per day,
Speaker:do I have lots of sentences go around it?
Speaker:Absolutely, I build
Speaker:those extra little things,
Speaker:but I don't care about that,
Speaker:I really care about those
Speaker:five sentences, like you said.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:So I start the next day by
Speaker:reviewing the previous slide,
Speaker:by asking, who's our
Speaker:character, how old are they,
Speaker:where are they right now,
Speaker:what happened, what did he do,
Speaker:I do all of that, so then they're getting
Speaker:a little bit of a
Speaker:review, practicing that one,
Speaker:before I start the new one,
Speaker:and then I do oral slide,
Speaker:the next day we write up the slide,
Speaker:so I ask the same questions, but now
Speaker:we're writing it up.
Speaker:So we're getting two hits
Speaker:at the apple for every slide,
Speaker:one written, yeah, one hit,
Speaker:one orally, and one written,
Speaker:so they can see how it's written,
Speaker:and with the written I usually elaborate,
Speaker:I just got observed on
Speaker:Friday, last, no, I'm sorry,
Speaker:on Tuesday, we talked about it on Friday,
Speaker:and one of the things she noted was,
Speaker:I like how you show them how to build
Speaker:more advanced sentences,
Speaker:because you have the sentences,
Speaker:you wrote them down really simply,
Speaker:and then I go, and here's how you can
Speaker:make it more advanced,
Speaker:and I'll write it down for that,
Speaker:it's the
Speaker:differentiation for the other kids,
Speaker:so I'm perfectly fine taking
Speaker:the short choppy sentences,
Speaker:but here is how you
Speaker:can build that sentence
Speaker:to make it more advanced, and I'll say,
Speaker:I go, here's how we can
Speaker:make the same sentence
Speaker:a little bit more
Speaker:advanced, we can add an and here,
Speaker:or we can add a because
Speaker:here, or we can add a therefore,
Speaker:I use teach them por eso,
Speaker:for that type of a thing,
Speaker:so that really works well with that,
Speaker:so my kids get for every slide,
Speaker:which is one sentence with dialogue,
Speaker:every slide has a sentence
Speaker:and it also has dialogue on it,
Speaker:the kids said dialogue,
Speaker:so I can get the first,
Speaker:second, and third person
Speaker:practiced in that one slide,
Speaker:and I work on one
Speaker:slide a day, that is it,
Speaker:that's enough for them,
Speaker:that is enough for them,
Speaker:and I keep-- We're trying to build
Speaker:memory muscles, that's enough, yeah.
Speaker:That's enough, and it
Speaker:keeps me narrow and deep
Speaker:when I go that way,
Speaker:because I stick on that slide
Speaker:for at least a half an hour,
Speaker:so they're really getting all that input,
Speaker:and then the next day we
Speaker:review it by typing it up,
Speaker:and then the next day we do the oral,
Speaker:but then I go back and I ask questions
Speaker:about the first slide
Speaker:orally, just a couple minutes,
Speaker:and then get right into the second slide,
Speaker:we do that one and then we write it up,
Speaker:so there's plenty of
Speaker:opportunities for there,
Speaker:the accountability, in my
Speaker:learning management system,
Speaker:I can assign something
Speaker:specifically to one kid,
Speaker:so I could say if I want
Speaker:them to look at the pictures
Speaker:I posted on there, I
Speaker:could give an assignment
Speaker:that tells them to do
Speaker:this and make four sentences
Speaker:with the vocab that I took a picture of,
Speaker:and then they did it or they didn't,
Speaker:so that's how you can
Speaker:hold them accountable
Speaker:and just that student
Speaker:and not everybody else,
Speaker:so you can do that as well.
Speaker:Oh, that's very cool.
Speaker:So let's see, students who are,
Speaker:that's the one I just did, the last one.
Speaker:Let's copy and paste this one.
Speaker:This is gonna be a
Speaker:record length for podcasts,
Speaker:you might show--
Speaker:It is, because we just
Speaker:hit the two hour mark.
Speaker:Let it party, let it party.
Speaker:Yeah, okay, missing CI in
Speaker:the moment is irreplaceable,
Speaker:I agree, there is no substituting
Speaker:for all those combined elements in the
Speaker:acquisition process,
Speaker:that is true for education in general
Speaker:when done by
Speaker:professionals, you cannot replace humans
Speaker:in human interaction
Speaker:when teaching and learning,
Speaker:our brains are programmed
Speaker:to make the most of that
Speaker:immediacy and spontaneity, absolutely,
Speaker:there's no question
Speaker:there, it's just a comment,
Speaker:but that's a good comment to end on.
Speaker:That really--
Speaker:That kinda wraps it all up, doesn't it?
Speaker:Yep. Yeah.
Speaker:We are not obsolete,
Speaker:we are not gonna be
Speaker:replaced by Rosetta Stone
Speaker:or any iteration thereof,
Speaker:and we're not gonna be replaced by AI,
Speaker:it's just not gonna
Speaker:happen, language is a,
Speaker:in fact I watched a video about that,
Speaker:saying that about teachers,
Speaker:but do we still need to
Speaker:learn languages with all this AI
Speaker:that you can talk into your earphones,
Speaker:and then the earphones come back and
Speaker:translate it for you,
Speaker:and then you have a
Speaker:conversation with someone else
Speaker:in English and they
Speaker:speak Chinese back to you
Speaker:and it's going back and forth,
Speaker:and I think you're
Speaker:losing the point of language.
Speaker:Communicate.
Speaker:We don't learn a language to be academic,
Speaker:we learn a language to communicate,
Speaker:and hearing your own language
Speaker:or someone even
Speaker:attempting your own language
Speaker:is the sweetest
Speaker:compliment that you could ever get,
Speaker:that someone cares
Speaker:enough about you to try,
Speaker:no matter how badly to
Speaker:speak your own language,
Speaker:it shows that you
Speaker:appreciate them as a human being,
Speaker:you appreciate where they
Speaker:come from, it's a big deal,
Speaker:and I think you cannot take
Speaker:the human out of language.
Speaker:Yes, do we have translators who can do it
Speaker:much quicker than we can?
Speaker:Yes, as well as we can, I don't think so
Speaker:because the nuance isn't there.
Speaker:They're missing all the culture,
Speaker:so many businesses get in trouble
Speaker:because they don't
Speaker:understand that in France,
Speaker:you're never gonna take responsibility
Speaker:for any mistakes that happen.
Speaker:In America, you're gonna
Speaker:be apologizing all the time.
Speaker:Those two companies are
Speaker:going to have problems
Speaker:when they're trying to work together.
Speaker:Or in Japan, we're at the business card,
Speaker:I don't know if it still is,
Speaker:but when I met my
Speaker:friends in Japan in the 80s,
Speaker:they said that
Speaker:business card is everything,
Speaker:they don't have to have an
Speaker:attractive business card.
Speaker:And Americans take the business card
Speaker:and they stick it in their back pocket
Speaker:and they're sitting on it, no, no, no.
Speaker:It is a big deal.
Speaker:When in Rome, learn, do as the Romans,
Speaker:you have to understand all these things
Speaker:and I don't think AI is
Speaker:ever going to get there for us.
Speaker:They don't know, they're taking language
Speaker:from what they find on the internet,
Speaker:what they scrape through the internet,
Speaker:and yes, can they, and
Speaker:they're not even getting
Speaker:all the words right because I had one.
Speaker:A kid asked me and I
Speaker:didn't know the answer.
Speaker:So he goes, so obvio is obvious?
Speaker:And I go, yeah, that's obvious.
Speaker:And he goes, what about what's obvioso?
Speaker:And I'm like, we use obviosamente,
Speaker:but I don't think I've
Speaker:ever heard obvioso, right?
Speaker:Obvioso?
Speaker:Yeah, so I looked it
Speaker:up and the first thing
Speaker:when you put it in Google.
Speaker:I don't know this either.
Speaker:Yeah, when you look it up in Google,
Speaker:you always get that AI overview first.
Speaker:And it says obvioso means obvious.
Speaker:But then when I scroll
Speaker:down to actually read
Speaker:actual websites,
Speaker:there is no word obvioso,
Speaker:it doesn't exist, which
Speaker:is weird because normally
Speaker:to get the adverb, when it's an OCE word,
Speaker:you make it feminine, you add the mente.
Speaker:So why isn't that obvio-mente?
Speaker:It's obviosamente.
Speaker:So it was really weird to me.
Speaker:Obvioso is, is it a noun?
Speaker:I don't know, but it
Speaker:was weird to look that up.
Speaker:Yeah, I don't know either.
Speaker:Okay, all right, I'll figure that out.
Speaker:I'll ask my colleagues
Speaker:if I can't figure it out.
Speaker:So it was, but it was wrong.
Speaker:So it was wrong and so
Speaker:it's not always right.
Speaker:I have a German
Speaker:colleague still complaining
Speaker:that every single
Speaker:translation of English to German
Speaker:is gonna say, well,
Speaker:blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
Speaker:And he says, it starts
Speaker:describing that thing with stones
Speaker:where there's water, even now.
Speaker:So. Yeah, yeah, it doesn't,
Speaker:and it doesn't know how
Speaker:many of our definitions of run
Speaker:we have in English.
Speaker:Yeah. Because run is,
Speaker:we use it way too much and get,
Speaker:we use that one way too much.
Speaker:I always tell my students, you know,
Speaker:you get a cold, do you get it?
Speaker:Do you get in trouble?
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:And even British English
Speaker:doesn't use get as much as we do.
Speaker:No, no, it's an American English.
Speaker:American English uses get a lot.
Speaker:So when it doesn't know
Speaker:the difference between those,
Speaker:it doesn't know the
Speaker:difference between the three dates,
Speaker:the fruit, the date on the calendar
Speaker:and the date you go on.
Speaker:It doesn't always, it's getting better,
Speaker:but it's still lots of times defaults
Speaker:to the date on the calendar
Speaker:because it's a more common word.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:So you can't rely on AI
Speaker:and I don't think we're
Speaker:gonna get replaced by AI
Speaker:anytime soon.
Speaker:That's my final say on that.
Speaker:As I said, I love to use AI.
Speaker:I am an AI, I like tech,
Speaker:I like where it's going.
Speaker:I like that we have it.
Speaker:I like that it's a
Speaker:tool, not a replacement.
Speaker:And I use it as a TA.
Speaker:That's, you know, it's not free
Speaker:because I gotta pay for it.
Speaker:But it's cheaper than a live person TA.
Speaker:And I don't, and not, and
Speaker:it's much more efficient.
Speaker:TA a lot more time to get
Speaker:some of the stuff that I want.
Speaker:Done, done.
Speaker:But I use it as a TA.
Speaker:I don't use it as a primary thinker.
Speaker:I do use it as a brainstormer.
Speaker:Sometimes it gives me
Speaker:some things, some ideas,
Speaker:or I can explore an idea with them.
Speaker:But I don't think AI
Speaker:is the end all be all.
Speaker:I don't think it's gonna replace.
Speaker:I think it's, we're in an era like
Speaker:in the industrial revolution
Speaker:time, you know, where that,
Speaker:you know, this is a new thing.
Speaker:It's gonna kill out some jobs,
Speaker:but it's gonna create some other ones.
Speaker:Yeah.
Speaker:I mean, a secretary, and
Speaker:I hate to say this one,
Speaker:but even if it's a
Speaker:secretary who just like keeps your
Speaker:calendar and stuff like
Speaker:that, that type of a secretary,
Speaker:that kind of job is
Speaker:gonna kind of get phased out
Speaker:where that
Speaker:secretary's job is gonna be more
Speaker:on the personal side,
Speaker:not just the organizing
Speaker:the life kind of thing.
Speaker:Just like we used to have
Speaker:the secretaries take dictation.
Speaker:Right.
Speaker:We don't do that anymore.
Speaker:So their job is going to evolve.
Speaker:Just keeping their calendar
Speaker:is not going to be that part
Speaker:of their job anymore
Speaker:because we've got so many things
Speaker:that can do it better and more
Speaker:efficiently than that.
Speaker:And it's not even just AI that does it.
Speaker:We have so many other things.
Speaker:You type things in
Speaker:your calendar all the time
Speaker:and put that in and keeps it much better
Speaker:than a secretary, good.
Speaker:So I think some of those lower end jobs
Speaker:are gonna be replaced, but
Speaker:it's gonna change the jobs
Speaker:to elevate just like it did during the
Speaker:industrial revolution.
Speaker:We would not have cars today,
Speaker:cars would be so expensive
Speaker:they were still made by hand
Speaker:before they came up with the assembly.
Speaker:Yeah, that's true.
Speaker:And they're already expensive.
Speaker:They're already expensive.
Speaker:Okay, with that, we've
Speaker:gone 208 minutes as a record.
Speaker:We should chop it in half
Speaker:so that people have something
Speaker:to listen to next week when we're off.
Speaker:Oh, that's good.
Speaker:Yeah, watch half of it
Speaker:now and half it later.
Speaker:Yeah. That's a good way.
Speaker:So that is our whopping episode 47.
Speaker:(laughing)
Speaker:That's a new record.
Speaker:Yes, thank you for spending your Sunday,
Speaker:your half your Sunday
Speaker:today, thinking through.
Speaker:(laughing) One of the hardest, Lee's
Speaker:talked about parts of our job
Speaker:and our job is much harder
Speaker:than it is for English teachers
Speaker:or math teachers to do this part.
Speaker:Pamela, thank you
Speaker:especially for sharing all the things
Speaker:that you did about interactive notebooks
Speaker:and all the other things that we did.
Speaker:You gave us lots of great ideas.
Speaker:That kind of patience just
Speaker:doesn't get enough credit.
Speaker:And I'll be honest, I'm not always the
Speaker:most patient of people.
Speaker:That's my autism coming through.
Speaker:It's hard.
Speaker:And I'm not autistic.
Speaker:And Kimberly, we
Speaker:definitely missed you today.
Speaker:So feel better soon and
Speaker:we'll catch you next time.
Speaker:So if you needed a better
Speaker:system for returning students
Speaker:or just proof that this problem is real
Speaker:and not something you're
Speaker:imagining, you got it today.
Speaker:Subscribe, leave a review
Speaker:and send this to a teacher
Speaker:who's currently watching
Speaker:a kid slip further behind
Speaker:through no fault of their own.
Speaker:Catch us live on
Speaker:YouTube or find the replay
Speaker:on your favorite
Speaker:podcast app, Ditch the Drills,
Speaker:Trust the Process and
Speaker:I'll see you next time
Speaker:on Comprehend This.
Speaker:Bye-bye everybody.
Speaker:I've been training us for this long time.
Speaker:Yes, and we'll see you in December.
Speaker:First weekend in
Speaker:December will be our next one.
Speaker:I think it's December 6th.
Speaker:December 6th.
Speaker:So we will see you then.
Speaker:Have a good one everybody.
Speaker:And until then, enjoy
Speaker:for those in America.
Speaker:Enjoy your Thanksgiving week.
Speaker:Bye-bye.
Speaker:(upbeat music)
